By Sumeet Chatterjee and Nigam Prusty
Dec 11 An Indian court ruling expected on
Thursday could determine whether Nokia will be free
to transfer a phone-making factory to Microsoft Corp or
pay as much as $3.4 billion in disputed taxes.
The Chennai plant is one of Nokia's biggest phone-making
factories and was seized by authorities because of tax claims.
Nokia appealed the seizure and has been trying to end the
dispute ahead of the sale of its mobile phone business to
Microsoft in a 5.4 billion euro ($7.4 billion) deal.
Nokia has said it wanted the factory seizure to be lifted by
Dec. 12 for the planned transfer of the business to Microsoft.
Nokia's case is one of several tax disputes involving
foreign companies in India, which has stepped up its pursuit of
claims against such firms as it seeks to rein in its budget
Companies recently involved in tax disputes in India include
IBM, Royal Dutch Shell, Vodafone Plc
and LG Electronics Inc.
In March, Nokia was served with a tax demand of about 20.8
billion rupees ($340.45 million) for five fiscal years starting
from 2006-07, according to a March 22 notice on the Delhi High
Including the anticipated liability, or the tax bill for the
years that have not been assessed by the authorities, the total
liability could rise to roughly 75 billion rupees, said Mohan
Parasaran, who is representing the tax department.
If Nokia loses the legal battle, it may have to pay as much
as 210 billion rupees ($3.44 billion), which includes penalties
and interest, Parasaran said. He declined to give additional
The penalty for non-payment of tax as per local rules can be
as high as up to three times the amount owed, tax experts said.
Nokia has said it had not been served with any claim beyond
the 20.8 billion rupee amount.
Nokia has said it does not expect the tax dispute to affect
its deal with Microsoft, which is likely to close in the first
quarter of 2014, but a lengthy asset freeze could complicate
matters by preventing the transfer of the Chennai plant.
Nokia did not have an immediate comment on Wednesday.
If the asset freeze continues, Nokia could operate the plant
as a contract manufacturer for Microsoft, but it would be a
distraction for the Finnish company's plans to focus on growing
its network equipment business.
It would also likely be temporary and Nokia could eventually
shut it down, depriving Microsoft of a crucial production site
in India. Nokia has invested more than $330 million in Chennai
since setting up the factory in 2006.
Nokia said earlier this week that it recently offered to pay
a 270 million euro ($369 million) deposit to Indian authorities,
on top of an earlier agreement to pay around 85 million euros,
to unfreeze assets including the Chennai plant.
The factory has about 7,000 staff and the Delhi High Court
said on Wednesday it would protect the interests of the workers.