TEP Officials Disappointed by ''Reckless'' Rate Proposals
TUCSON, Ariz.--(Business Wire)-- A pair of proposed alternatives to Tucson Electric Power's (TEP's) requested rate increase would compromise the utility's ability to provide safe, reliable service, company officials said today. TEP estimates that a proposal filed Friday by consultants to the staff of the Arizona Corporation Commission (ACC) would reduce current rates by 2 to 3 percent - even though the company currently charges less than it did in 1994. The state's Residential Utility Consumer Office (RUCO) also proposed rates lower than TEP's current retail average of 8.4 cents per kilowatt-hour. TEP has requested a 15 to 23 percent rate increase, but residential customers with average usage would see a smaller increase - from about 8 to 13 percent. "The proposals from staff's consultants and RUCO are simply reckless," said James S. Pignatelli, Chairman, President and CEO for TEP and its parent company, UniSource Energy Corporation (NYSE: UNS). "The rates proposed by staff's consultants and RUCO would not provide the increases we need to cover our rising costs and serve our customers' growing energy needs," Pignatelli said. "They clearly did not consider the financial impact their recommendations would have on this company." The ACC is expected to address TEP's rate request late this year. Before the commission votes, an administrative law judge (ALJ) will review testimony and evidence filed by TEP, ACC staff, RUCO and other parties and will prepare a recommended opinion and order. While consultants working for ACC staff recommended a nearly 10-percent reduction in TEP's base rates, they proposed a Purchased Power and Fuel Adjustment Clause (PPFAC) that would generate enough revenue to bring rates back up within 2 or 3 percent of current levels, Pignatelli said. That estimate is based on a natural gas price of $9 per million British Thermal Units. "The proposed PPFAC would at least help us recover our rising fuel and purchased power costs," Pignatelli said. "But after going more than a decade without a rate increase, a decrease in base rates would threaten our financial stability and, frankly, defies logic." ACC staff's consultants and RUCO advised against incorporating market power prices in rates through the alternate "market" and "hybrid" rate structures proposed by TEP. They also recommended that the ACC deny any compensation for the excess costs TEP incurred under terms of the 1999 agreement that capped the company's rates through the end of 2008. "These consultants are recommending that the state of Arizona simply ignore its obligations in the 1999 agreement, which would be a serious mistake given our performance under that contract," Pignatelli said. "We're early in the process, though, so the ACC still has plenty of time to work toward a resolution that recognizes TEP's costs and places TEP in the financial position it would have been in without the contract." TEP's rates were reduced three times between 1998 and 2000 and currently are lower than they were in 1994. Consumer prices have increased more than 40 percent since then, while the cost of labor, fuel, construction materials and other business needs have risen even more dramatically. In addition to facing higher operating costs, TEP is preparing to invest nearly $1.4 billion over the next five years in transmission lines, transformers, substations and other improvements that will be needed to serve customers' growing energy needs. The rates proposed by ACC staff and RUCO would deny TEP the revenues needed to fund such projects while increasing the company's borrowing costs. "I'm hopeful that the ALJ, commissioners and even the ACC staff itself will recognize the shortsighted nature of these consultants' proposals," Pignatelli said. "Their recommendations might appear to benefit customers, but they would increase our costs, reduce our ability to invest in service reliability and erode the financial stability we've worked so hard to re-establish at TEP." Copies of the proposals submitted by ACC staff consultants and RUCO as well as other materials from TEP's rate case are available online at uns.com. TEP expects to file its rebuttal testimony on April 1, and a hearing before the ALJ is scheduled to begin May 12. TEP, a subsidiary of UniSource Energy, provides safe, reliable electric service to nearly 400,000 customers in the Tucson metropolitan area. For more information about the company, visit TEP.com. For more information about UniSource Energy, visit uns.com. This news release contains forward-looking information that involves risks and uncertainties that include, but are not limited to: the outcome of regulatory proceedings and the rate levels TEP, UNS Gas and UNS Electric are authorized to charge their customers; changes in accounting standards; regional economic and market conditions which could affect customer growth and the cost of fuel and power supplies; changes to long-term contracts; performance of TEP's generating plants; the weather; changes in asset depreciable lives; changes related to the recognition of unbilled revenue; the cost of debt and equity capital; the ongoing restructuring of the electric industry; and other factors listed in UniSource Energy's Form 10-K and 10-Q filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The preceding factors may cause future results to differ materially from outcomes currently expected by UniSource Energy. Tucson Electric Power Joe Salkowski, 520-884-3625 (News Media) Jo Smith, 520-884-3650 (Financial Analyst) Copyright Business Wire 2008
© Thomson Reuters 2008 All rights reserved








