RPT-PREVIEW-Japan-Australia '08 thermal coal price record-bound
(Repeats item first sent Jan 24)
By Fayen Wong and Osamu Tsukimori
SYDNEY/TOKYO, Jan 24 (Reuters) - Japanese utilities have begun what will be lengthy talks with some Australian producers for 2008 thermal coal contracts that analysts say could be sealed at a record-high above $90 amid tight global supplies.
Marketing teams from Xstrata Plc (XTA.L) and Rio Tinto Ltd (RIO.AX) are in Tokyo this week, hoping to negotiate a near 80 percent jump in contract prices at about $100 a tonne, but Japanese buyers are seeking between $15-20 below that.
Miners and analysts have said coal supplies were set to tighten significantly this year on continued supply constraints in Australia and Indonesia as well as growing Asian demand, particularly in China and India.
"Our forecast is for prices to be settled at $90 but recent developments would suggest that there are some upside risks to the price," said Malcolm Southwood, a resource analyst at Goldman Sachs in Melbourne.
"The emergence of China and India as major importers has been a critical factor in tipping the market balance. And when you add supply constraints in Australia and South Africa into the equation, you get a very tight market."
Macquarie Bank and UBS have raised their forecasts for the 2008 contract prices between the two parties, which will start in April, by nearly 60 percent to about $90 a tonne. [ID:nSYD143]
LONG-DRAWN OUT TALKS
Rio Tinto's initial offer to Japanese utilities would be in the range of "high-$90s to low-$100s", an executive told Reuters on condition of anonymity because of company policy.
"The market is a lot tighter this year. But some Japanese utilities are still hoping to get something at mid-$80s or even low-$90 levels, which I think is quite impossible," he said.
"This could be a long-drawn out negotiation."
One Japanese utility source even indicated its opening bid would be up to $79, more than $10 below prices on the globalCOAL NEWC index, versus last year's contract price of $55.65.
Industry sources said Xstrata and Rio have yet to put in firm offers, as prices on the index, commonly used as a benchmark for coal prices in Asia, were still hovering in the low-$90s.
This signals that they may be targeting higher levels on forecasts of even tighter supplies and rising demand from Japan and China, which are grappling with power shortages due to high prices of other fuels as well as outages.
But prices at $100-levels, free-on-board (FOB) basis, would be a historic high and Japanese utilities, such as Chubu Electric (9502.T) and Tohoku Electric (9506.T), are expected to offer fierce resistance during the meetings, which have so far been informal.
"Offers in the mid-$90s is a sharp increase and is totally different from what we have in mind. It will be hard to accept a three-digit figure," said a company official from one of the smaller Japanese utilities.
Other Japanese buyers said it was unreasonable for prices
to jump this high when South Korean utilities managed to ink
their 2008 coal contracts at about $60 a tonne. Some Japanese
utilities have also agreed with Indonesia's Bumi Resources
(BUMI.JK) to buy 2008 coal supplies at about $85 a tonne in
November.
Producers say that each contract signed will take tonnage out of an available supply pool, which will in turn tighten supplies further and push up prices.
And analysts noted that China's export prices are even higher.
EYES ON CHINA
Chinese producers, including Shenhua Energy Co Ltd (1088.HK) and Datong Coal (601001.SS), are also in Tokyo this week to negotiate for 2008 term contracts, but industry sources said they too have yet to throw in an offer.
"They are waiting to see what Xstrata or Rio is offering. Everyone is having a wait-and-see attitude and waiting for someone else to make the first move," said a Tokyo-based trader who declined to be identified.
Two market sources said Shenhua has recently settled a 2008 thermal coal contract with a Japanese utility at $98, FOB basis, for 300,000 tonnes of coal. The contract was for coal with calorific value of 5,800 kcal/kg net as received basis. With a freight advantage of more than $10 a tonne, industry watchers said Chinese miners were unlikely to put in an offer that is cheaper than Australian producers.
"Coal from China takes only five days to arrive in Japan, while Australian coal takes about two weeks to be delivered. Apart from that, there are also congestion issues and reliability when it comes to Australian producers," said a trader from a European trading firm.
Supplies from China, which is expected to emerge as a net coal importer this year, would also be limited as domestic demand surges.
Japan faces mounting competition for coal produced in Australia -- its main supplier -- from South Korea, China and India. Supplies from other regional exporters such as Indonesia and Vietnam are also limited due to their own rising needs for the fuel.
In the 2006 fiscal year, Japan imported 179 million tonnes of coal, of which about 60 percent came from Australia, 20 percent from Indonesia and 12 percent from China. HISTORICAL BENCHMARK THERMAL COAL CONTRACT PRICES -------------------------------------------------
YEAR PRICE (US$/TONNE) Japan FY 07/08 55.65 Japan FY 06/07 51.85 Japan FY 05/06 53.00 Japan FY 04/05 42.00 Japan FY 03/04 26.80 Japan FY 02/03 31.90 (Editing by Ramthan Hussain)
© Thomson Reuters 2009 All rights reserved

