By Ronnie Cohen
San Francisco, Sept 3 Software mogul Larry
Ellison's Oracle Team USA suffered a major setback in its effort
to retain the America's Cup sailing trophy when an international
jury on Tuesday docked the team two points and kicked three team
members out of the event for adding illegal weight to Oracle
The penalties, unprecedented in the history of the
162-year-old event, are a big boost for challenger Emirates Team
New Zealand, which will face off against Oracle in the Cup
finals beginning on Saturday. New Zealand demolished other
would-be challengers in the qualifying races, and bookmakers
have made it a slight favorite to take the trophy from Oracle.
The Cup finals are a best-of-17 series, and Oracle will now
enter the event two points behind: it will need to win 11 races
to win the series, while New Zealand will only need to win 9.
Oracle will also be sailing without a key crew member, Dirk de
Ridder, a 40-year-old Dutchman who was banished from the event
for his role in the weight scandal.
Another Oracle sailor was suspended for the first 4 races,
and two shore crew members were barred from any further
The scandal first came to light in July, when 45-foot Oracle
catamarans that had been used for a preliminary series known as
the America's Cup World Series of Racing - and were raced again
last week in a youth competition - were found to have illegal
bags of lead and resin wedged into their frames.
Oracle said the team had gained no advantage from the extra
weight and that the skippers and team's managers were unaware of
the alterations, but it nonetheless agreed to forfeit its World
Series victories. The 45-foot catamarans, unlike the 72-foot
boats being used in the main event, were a "one-design" class,
meaning all teams were supposed to have exactly the same boat.
An international jury of five sailing experts was charged
with investigating the situation. In a report released Tuesday,
it said it had found five instances of prohibited modifications
in three Oracle boats.
"The incidents are serious and unprecedented in the
America's Cup," the jury report said. "The seriousness of the
breaches cannot be understated."
Oracle was also ordered to pay $250,000 in penalties to two
"The rules infractions involved only a few of our 130 team
members, and were done without the knowledge of either our
team's management or the skippers who were driving the boats,"
said Oracle team CEO Russell Coutts in a statement.
"While we disagree with the unprecedented penalties imposed
by the jury, we have no choice but to make the necessary changes
to personnel on our race boat and do our best to use the next
four days for the new team to practice and get ready for the
start of the 34th America's Cup."
For Ellison, who won the Cup in a controversial 2010 match
off the coast of Spain, the sanctions are the latest
embarrassment in a Cup regatta where little has gone as planned.
With many potential participants scared off by the cost and
complexity of the AC72 boats, only three teams challenged for
the Cup, undermining the economics of the event. A training
accident in May killed a British sailor and forced contentious
safety-related changes in the rules.
Attendance is also far below projections, with most in San
Francisco paying little attention to the event.
Still, many observers expect the finals series to be
competitive, which could yet vindicate Ellison's decision to use
high-tech catamarans that can reach speeds of more than 50 miles
Ellison has not commented publicly on the cheating scandal.