By Jesús Aguado and Sarah White
MADRID, June 24 Spain's economy minister said on
Monday he would not be pushed into selling two nationalised
banks too quickly or too cheaply as bankers press the government
to act to resolve the lingering problems of its financial
Bankers say that Spain must pump more funds into some of the
lenders it bailed out last year using EU aid and its own money
if it hopes to sell them soon, with the government's options for
recovering some of the investment narrowing.
A recent government-commissioned report on the sector by
investment bank Nomura and consultancy McKinsey suggested
quickly selling Catalunya Banc and NCG Banco before
their assets deteriorate further, two banking sources said.
Economy Minister Luis de Guindos said on Monday that the
government was exploring all options for the sale of the two
banks, although he said there was no rush.
"The buyers always try to give the impression that things
are worth less than what they are... We are convinced that these
entities have value," de Guindos told COPE radio on Monday.
"We have to do it at the right moment and the process must
be competitive... We have five years to do it, there's no need
to rush. I know there are some that want it to go quickly."
Barcelona-based Catalunya Banc and NCG Banco, from the
northern region of Galicia, together worth less than 10 percent
of the Spanish market, were among the biggest recipients of the
41 billion euros ($55 billion) Madrid took from Brussels in aid
Fernando Restoy, deputy head of Spain's central bank, opened
the door on Friday to an asset protection scheme to speed up the
sale of the banks, although he repeated the government's view
that they do not need more capital.
Bankers say potential bidders are demanding guarantees
against losses, or more capital, even though the banks are now
mostly cleansed of the soured property assets that nearly felled
But pumping extra funds into the banks would hinder Spain's
attempts to slash its deficit in a prolonged recession, as it
faces public anger over deep public spending cuts.
It would also bring the money spent on saving Catalunya Banc
closer to its cost of liquidation. Under the terms of the
European bailout, Spain cannot spend more on capitalising a bank
than it would on winding it down.
"There is interest in these banks," one senior Madrid
investment banker said. "But that interest is at a price which
is very different to where the government's price is. Buyers
essentially want to get money to buy them, as bank acquisitions
in Spain have been more sour than sweet as norms keep changing
and provisioning needs keep rising."
No formal process to sell the banks is yet underway, several
bankers familiar with their situation said, although informal
conversations with investors are taking place.
Spain has spent over 75 billion euros to help 14 banks in
the past four years. With many still facing big hurdles as they
recover from 2008's domestic property crash, it has the option
to draw down more of a 100 billion euro aid line from Europe.
While Bankia, the biggest lender in state hands, became a
symbol of Spain's financial turmoil when it needed a 22.5
billion euro rescue barely a year after listing, Catalunya Banc
has turned into the government's most immediate problem.
Spain aborted its last attempt to sell Catalunya Banc in
March when those interested - some of Spain's healthier lenders
- requested government-funded schemes to protect them against
future losses, or other types of aid.
Two financial sources familiar with the lender's accounts
said bidders have identified additional losses of between 3
billion and 4 billion euros at the bank due to souring loans to
households and companies.
A spokeswoman for the bank denied it faced a 3 to 4 billion
euro hole but said it had not conducted analysis of projected
losses under new provisioning rules.
For comparison, liquidating Catalunya would have cost 17.8
billion euros, the bank disclosed in a stock market filing this
month. It has received 12 billion euros in state aid so far.
The bank made a loss of 18.5 million euros in the first
quarter of 2013 and its loans in arrears rose to 9.91 percent of
outstanding loans at the end of March from 9.39 percent at end
December. The average for the whole Spanish sector was 10.5
percent - compared to less than 7 percent in the euro zone.
NCG Banco returned to profit in the same period, but its bad
debt ratio grew to 14.4 percent at the end of March from 13.5
percent in December.
It has made some progress shedding assets, however, and is
close to clinching the sale of parts of its branch networks
outside Galicia, a source close to the bank said.