FACTBOX-Quotes on Guantanamo case at U.S. Supreme Court

Mon Dec 3, 2007 8:38am EST
 
[-] Text [+]

(Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court hears arguments on Wednesday in a case to decide the legal rights of terrorism suspects held in the U.S. detention center at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. Following are quotes about the case taken from legal briefs and interviews.

U.S. GOVERNMENT (in court brief):

"Congress has authorized a war against an international terrorist organization with no uniformed soldiers, and the detention of its members and supporters is a critical component of any such war."

JENNIFER DASKAL, HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH (interview):

"This is such a central issue to the United States. It's not just about the Guantanamo detainees. It's about basic checks and balances and the U.S. system of government, and ensuring that even the president is not above the law."

U.N. HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS (in court brief):

"The United States is obliged to respect and ensure the rights set forth in (the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights). The current system fails to do so. This court should ensure that provisions of domestic law are construed and applied consistent with the United States's continued commitment to the protection of human rights."

RETIRED U.S. MILITARY OFFICERS (in court brief): "If the United States detains 'enemy combatants' without providing a fair and meaningful hearing, it increases the likelihood that foreign forces capturing American troops in the future will ignore the Geneva conventions entirely -- thereby putting the lives of American prisoners at risk."

THE FOUNDATION FOR DEFENSE OF DEMOCRACIES (in court brief)

"(Granting detainees broad rights to challenge their confinement) would invite massive detainee litigation, clogging the federal courts and enabling our enemies to wage a propaganda war against us using the platform of our own legal system."

WASHINGTON LEGAL FOUNDATION AND RETIRED GENERALS AND ADMIRALS (in court brief):

"The United States can be justly proud of the humane and fair manner in which it has treated those prisoners (at Guantanamo). In particular, the Executive Branch and Congress have worked together to devise a system for ensuring that prisoners not charged with crimes do not remain in detention."

DAVID CYNAMON, LEAD ATTORNEY FOR DETAINEE FAWZI AL ODAH AND OTHERS IN THE CASE (in interview):

"Our clients ... have remained in pretty good shape mentally and physically. As this stretches out, they certainly have no belief or faith in the American system of justice. When I tell them about the Supreme Court arguments coming up, they said: 'That's just a joke. Two years ago we were told that the Supreme Court had ruled in our favor and we're still here.'"

(Reporting by Randall Mikkelsen; Editing by David Alexander and Peter Cooney)

 

Featured Broker sponsored link

Editor's Choice

A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours.  Slideshow 

Most Popular on Reuters

  • Articles
  • Video

Analysis

A woman and a child wear masks as they wait for a H1N1 flu check-up at a temporary H1N1 flu treatment centre at a hospital in Seoul November 3, 2009.   REUTERS/Choi Bu-Seok
Swine flu skepticism demands deft response

European scientists and health authorities are facing angry questions about why H1N1 flu has not caused death and destruction on the scale first feared, and they need to respond deftly to ensure public support.  Full Article | Full Coverage