HONG KONG (Reuters Breakingviews) - Taiwan faces a bigger threat than Chinese invasion: its own economic mismanagement. President Tsai Ing-wen has outlined plans to bolster growth, including a $29 billion stimulus package, but bolder reforms favoured by the business community look hobbled by politics. The irony is that a politician whose party is defined by resistance to Beijing may leave Taiwan more dependent on the mainland than ever.
Parked 110 miles to the southeast of China, the self-ruled island of 23.5 million people has long been a strategic irritant to its giant neighbour, which views Taiwan as a renegade province and resents its de-facto military alliance with the United States. It is thus a potential military flashpoint.
But Taiwan is also a positive example. It is one of the few economies to escape the so-called middle-income trap and achieve developed status by turning itself into a tech export powerhouse. Today, Taiwan is a critical part of the global tech supply chain, hosting the $162 billion chipmaker TSMC and Foxconn, a key Apple supplier. Its average GDP per capita on a purchasing power basis was over three times higher than China’s in 2016.
The capital of Taipei shows what an advanced ethnically Chinese economy can achieve under a democracy: a comfortable, low-key lifestyle. Taipei’s streets are full of organic coffee shops, bubble tea stands and food markets, which the friendly Taiwanese drive through on hordes of colourful scooters.
Unfortunately growth has been low-key too. The Kuomintang party, which once dominated Taiwanese politics, is seen as pro-business. Yet the benefits of the party’s policy of closer ties with Beijing in recent years have not trickled down to the broader middle class. Frustration over this state of affairs handed Tsai and her independence-leaning Democratic Progressive Party a decisive electoral victory last January. The KMT is now in disarray; with the opposition crippled, Tsai and the DPP-controlled legislature have focused on catering to the base.
Graphic: Taiwan’s decade of low growth: reut.rs/2oCHWwl
Ties with China have duly deteriorated since. Tsai has refused to make the standard public statement that China and Taiwan are a single country, drawing retaliation from Beijing in sectors like tourism. Yet even if she concedes on this issue, the reality is that demand from the mainland, the world’s largest consumer of smartphones and other electronics, is softening, and Taiwan is over-exposed to both China and tech. Exports make up almost two thirds of Taiwan’s economic output, of which over 40 percent goes to China and Hong Kong. Last year tech components made up 44 percent of total exports. At the same time Taiwan faces more competition from firms in other countries, including the mainland itself, and emerging manufacturing hubs like Vietnam.
The average growth rate has thus halved compared to the years before the global financial crisis, with GDP forecast to expand just under 2 percent this year. Wages have flattened even as housing prices leap upward. Joblessness, currently at 3.8 percent, is expected to improve this year, but educated workers and younger people still struggle to find good work. Many are leaving: some 724,000 Taiwanese work abroad, according to government statistics, more than doubled from a decade earlier. Over half are in China.
Graphic: Taiwan labour market malaise: reut.rs/2oX0sTp
To revitalise the economy, the DPP has a combination of social reforms, industrial policies and trade initiatives. Last month the government unveiled an eight-year $29 billion stimulus package targeting infrastructure projects in railways, water, green energy and the digital economy. To reduce reliance on electronics, the government is trying to boost investment into areas like biotech and defence. It also wants to expand trade with Southeast Asia.
Scepticism runs high. It’s not clear if the fiscal package can be fully implemented, for one: Tsai’s term ends halfway through the plan. And top-down industrial policies promoting new sectors look unlikely to be transformative. Critics have attacked the “Asia Silicon Valley Development Plan” for ignoring more fundamental handbrakes on growth, like red tape and restrictions on foreign investment and talent. Taiwan may still hold 14th place in the World Economic Forum’s Global Competitiveness Index, yet it ranks a dismal 87th place in terms of openness to foreign capital, down from 16th in 2014.
Tsai’s approach also puts her at odds with the business community. The DPP’s promises to improve benefits and lift the minimum wage, for example, please her labour-oriented base. But they have alienated private employers who want more liberalisation, not higher costs. At the same time, her popularity is sliding: a February poll showed her approval rating had dropped around 29 percentage points since inauguration.
The KMT’s pro-China policies may have hollowed out the domestic economy by encouraging Taiwanese capital to outsource production to China – a political issue in other countries as well. But if the DPP wants more economic independence from the mainland, its plan looks unlikely to deliver.
(The DPP’s full name has been corrected to Democratic Progressive (not People‘s) Party in paragraph five of this item.)
Reuters Breakingviews is the world's leading source of agenda-setting financial insight. As the Reuters brand for financial commentary, we dissect the big business and economic stories as they break around the world every day. A global team of about 30 correspondents in New York, London, Hong Kong and other major cities provides expert analysis in real time.
Sign up for a free trial of our full service at https://www.breakingviews.com/trial and follow us on Twitter @Breakingviews and at www.breakingviews.com. All opinions expressed are those of the authors.