WASHINGTON Oct 30 Members of a select
House-Senate panel on Wednesday targeted for potential repeal a
U.S. meat-labeling law that Mexico and Canada have challenged as
a violation of world trade rules, and that U.S. meatpackers also
The country-of-origin labeling (COOL) law requires labels on
packages of beef, pork, poultry and lamb sold in U.S. stores to
carry specific information on the source of the meat. The U.S.
terms it a "consumer information" program.
While favored by consumer groups, COOL has been a lightning
rod for dispute for more than a decade. Congress approved
meat-origin labeling in 2002, but it did not become mandatory
The United States re-wrote the regulations this year in an
attempt to satisfy a 2012 World Trade Organization ruling, but
has been challenged again at the WTO.
At the first negotiating session on a final version of the
new $500 billion U.S. farm bill, several lawmakers said COOL
should be revised or repealed, in part because of the risk of
"I am hopeful that working together we can prevent the
imposition of tariffs on a wide array of products important to
many states," said House Agriculture Committee chairman Frank
Lucas in an opening statement. Under congressional protocol, he
chairs the farm bill talks.
Canada and Mexico say the law led to a decline in sales of
their cattle and hogs because of additional costs to handle
them. U.S. meatpackers say COOL is a bookkeeping headache that
also drives up costs.
Defenders such as the National Farmers Union and the
Consumer Federation of America say COOL help shoppers make
informed decisions on their meat purchases. They said there is
no need for Congress to intervene.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture says COOL is not a food
safety or traceability program. Foreign food products must still
meet U.S. food safety standards.
Republican Senator Pat Roberts from Kansas, one of the
largest U.S. cattle states, said he would support a House
provision that was under development and expected to be a repeal
clause for COOL.
Senate Agriculture chairwoman Debbie Stabenow said COOL
"clearly is one of the issues" for farm bill negotiators.
As the farm bill conference kicked off, negotiators, with a
target of completing work before year-end, remain divided on
potential cuts to food stamp funding, but are agree on many
other elements of the legislation.
President Barack Obama last week listed the farm bill as one
of three priorities for completion this year. The administration
has not spelled out how it will take part in the bill's final
Conservative Republicans want to cut food stamps by $39
billion over a decade, the largest cuts in at least a generation
and 10 times the amount proposed by the Senate.
Food stamp recipients, about one of every seven Americans,
will see an average 7 percent drop in benefits on Friday with
the expiration of assistance that was part of the 2009 economic