By Lawrence Hurley
WASHINGTON, March 31 The U.S. Supreme Court on
Monday agreed to hear an appeal filed by Teva Pharmaceutical
Industries Ltd in a patent fight over top-selling
multiple sclerosis drug Copaxone, a move that could deter
generic manufacturers from introducing cheaper versions onto the
market as soon as May.
By agreeing to hear the case, the high court cast into doubt
a July 2013 ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit in favor of two teams developing cheaper generic forms
of Copaxone: one involving Novartis AG's Sandoz Inc and
Momenta Pharmaceuticals Inc and another involving Mylan
Inc and Natco Pharma Ltd.
The appeals court had upheld some of nine patents involved
in the drug, or portions thereof, but declared several invalid,
meaning patent protections were set to expire in May 2014
instead of September 2015.
With that outcome now uncertain, Teva likely has more time
to switch patients over to a new version of the medicine.
Copaxone, the leading treatment for multiple sclerosis, has been
by far Teva's most important product.
Even though Teva is the world's largest maker of generic
drugs, its branded Copaxone has accounted for about 20 percent
of company sales and 50 percent of its profits.
In late January, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration
approved the more convenient new version of Copaxone that is
taken three times a week instead of daily.
Israel-based Teva has said it believes it will be able to
get 45 percent of regular Copaxone patients to switch to the new
drug. However, it is critically important to get as many
patients switched over as possible before cheap generic versions
of the original Copaxone begin to flood the market.
Analysts have said Teva's strategy of switching patients to
the new three times a week Copaxone is going well so far.
"Our recent multiple sclerosis survey indicates that 25
percent of current Copaxone patients will be switched by June,
about 33 percent by year end and 40 percent in two years,"
Leerink Partners analyst Jason Gerberry said in a research note.
"Further, we've gotten feedback from payers that they won't
force patients off three times weekly if a generic 20 mg (daily
Copaxone) becomes available, so we view near-term conversion
rates as a key determinant of the future generic market size,"
Oral arguments and a ruling are expected in the court's next
term, which begins in October and ends in June 2015. The case is
Teva v. Sandoz, U.S. Supreme Court, 13-854.
(Reporting by Lawrence Hurley; Additional reporting by Bill
Berkrot; Editing by Howard Goller)