* Nine of 20 retailers miss estimates
* Clothing retailers lift profit outlook
* April sales up 0.8 percent - Thomson Reuters index
By Nivedita Bhattacharjee
May 3 Several large U.S. retailers, including
Target Corp, Macy's Inc and Gap Inc,
missed sales estimates for April, in sync with broader economic
indicators and as cooler weather chilled some of the enthusiasm
shoppers had shown earlier this year.
An earlier Easter also hurt April sales by shifting demand
Of the 20 retailers tracked by Thomson Reuters, nine missed
Wall Street estimates of April sales at stores open at least a
The Thomson Reuters same-store sales index showed a rise of
0.8 percent, short of analysts' estimates for an increase of 1.5
percent. Sales in March had risen 4.3 percent.
"The past few months have all been exaggerated," said Kit
Yarrow, a consumer psychologist and professor at the Golden Gate
"Many seem to be looking for the magic moment when the
recession is fully behind us. That just won't happen ... it's
like being on a diet and checking the scale every morning."
Retail Metrics analyst Ken Perkins said about one-third of
the cooling in sales was a result of broader economic
conditions, adding that May will be a better gauge for consumer
spending, because April sales also saw a big pull back from the
In April, the S&P 500 posted its first monthly decline since
November on signs that the U.S. economy may be slowing and as a
recession in Spain highlighted risks in the euro zone.
"While a majority of chains missed expectations this month
... the earnings guidance coming out retailers was quite
positive," he said.
Clothing retailers, including Gap and Aeropostale Inc
, said their earnings in the just-ended fiscal first
quarter should come in above analysts' expectations as they were
able to rein in discounts and keep inventory under control.
"It is possible to increase profit and margins sometimes at
the expense of sales, and that is not always visible in monthly
sales numbers," said Joel Bines, managing director of
AlixPartners' retail practice.
TJX Cos Inc, operator of the T.J. Maxx and Marshalls
low-price chains, also raised its profit estimate after doing so
The Standard & Poor's Retail Index fell 1.2 percent
in afternoon trading, while the broad S&P 500 stock index
was down nearly 1 percent. Shares of Zumiez, whose 10.1
percent gain topped all other chains, were up 1.02 percent.
THE CALENDAR EFFECT
Many industry experts like to look at March and April sales
in combination, to account for the calendar shifts.
March results benefited because of an early Easter -- April
8 this year, compared with April 24 in 2011. It was also the
warmest March in more than 50 years, which helped spur sales of
Combined, March and April same-store sales were up 4.6
percent, excluding drugstores, said Michael Niemira.
That increase was "a little bit on the softer side relative
to the year-to-date trend, but not dramatically so," he said.
For May, the ICSC expects same-store sales to increase 4
percent to 5 percent.
HITS AND MISSES
Macy's April same-store sales rose 1.2 percent, below the
1.9 percent increase analysts were expecting. The department
store chain blamed the earlier Easter and later Mother's Day for
the slower growth.
Target posted a 1.1 percent rise, missing the analysts'
average forecast of 2.8 percent. The discount chain said an
increase in the average transaction's value had offset a slight
decline in the number of comparable-store transactions.
Gap's same-store sales fell 2 percent, which was worse than
the 0.8 percent drop analysts were expecting.
Still, the company gave a quarterly earnings outlook above
Wall Street estimates, as did Aeropostale Inc and
American Eagle Outfitters Inc.
Apparel retailers have finally started selling closer to
full price after years of discounting. Bines said that while
tempered discounting may have hurt Gap's April sales, it helped
Victoria's Secret parent Limited Brands Inc posted a
6 percent rise in same-store sales, beating estimates.
One big disappointment was Costco Wholesale Corp.
The company missed Wall Street estimates for the second month in
a row, suggesting competition with other big-box retailers hurt
the biggest U.S. warehouse club operator's performance.
Its same-store sales rose 4 percent, while analysts were
expecting a 5.1 percent increase.
Costco, which competes with Wal-Mart Stores Inc's
Sam's Club and BJ's Wholesale, has been "a bit more aggressive
in terms of price to drive traffic," said Brian Sozzi, chief
equities analyst of NBG Productions.