Time asks Indonesian court to reverse Suharto libel ruling

Thu Feb 21, 2008 1:40am EST
 
[-] Text [+]

By Harry Suhartono

JAKARTA (Reuters) - Time magazine said on Thursday it had filed a petition to Indonesia's Supreme Court asking it to reverse a 1 trillion rupiah ($109 million) libel ruling in favor of former Indonesian President Suharto.

The case is seen by many analysts as an important test of Indonesia's legal system and freedom of speech.

Time, owned by Time Warner Inc, published a May 1999 cover story alleging that Suharto, who died in hospital last month aged 86, and his family had amassed a fortune of around $15 billion, including $9 billion in an Austrian bank account.

Time magazine won two appeals in lower courts, but in September 2007 the Supreme Court ruled in favor of Suharto and order Time to pay damages of over $100 million and to print apologies.

"The Court's judgment was a blow to the rights of a free press in Indonesia," Michael Elliott, editor of Time International, said in a statement issued on Thursday.

Time said it has asked a new panel of Supreme Court judges to reinstate the decision of the lower courts.

"The case is not just about Suharto versus Time, it's about freedom of the press versus authoritarian control of the press," said Todung Mulya Lubis, Time's legal counsel in Jakarta.

In its "Suharto Inc" story, Time wrote that Suharto's six children owned significant stakes in at least 564 companies in Indonesia, while their overseas interests included hundreds of other firms from the United States to Uzbekistan.

Suharto's salary was only $1,764 a month when he left office, the magazine said.

Suharto first filed a lawsuit against Time in 1999 seeking damages of 183 trillion rupiah, equivalent to nearly $20 billion at the current exchange rate.

Transparency International ranked Suharto as the world's leading kleptocrat with a fortune estimated at $15-$35 billion.

Attempts to bring criminal charges for graft against Suharto were dropped in 2001 because the supreme court justice at that time ruled he was too ill to stand trial.

($1=9185 Rupiah)

(Editing by Sara Webb and David Fox)

 

Analysis

Afghan President Hamid Karzai speaks during a news conference in Kabul November 3, 2009.  REUTERS/Ahmad Masood
Karzai image in tatters

Just how far Hamid Karzai's reputation has fallen is summed up by a cartoon in the Economist, which shows the newly re-elected Afghan leader seated at a table -- between Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and Robert Mugabe.   Full Article 

Photo

Editor's Choice

A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours.   Slideshow 

Most Popular on Reuters

  • Articles
  • Video
Shrimps boats are seen at the coastal area of Bayou La Batre, Alabama November 10, 2009.  REUTERS/Carlos Barria
Shrimpers struggle

Fishermen like Steve Patronas struggle to make a living, but high costs, low prices for their catches and competition from countries like Vietnam or China are putting many of them out of business and choking off their way of life.  Blog | Video