Reuters - Video

EDITION: U.S. | U.K. | IN

Rough Cuts

Prop 8 & Procreation: high court sails "uncharted waters"

Wednesday, Mar 27, 2013 - 04:51

United States Supreme Court justices - deeply divided - hear oral arguments and engage in debate on California's Proposition 8 law banning gay marriage, including whether the institution is really all about having babies.

▲ Hide Transcript

View Transcript

OK I've I. And it doesn't go right okay -- I don't -- -- As people throughout the country. He engaged in an earnest debate. Over whether the age old definition of marriage should be changed to include same sex couples. The question before this court. Is whether the constitution puts a stop to that ongoing democratic debate and answers this question for all -- These states in reading debris seems as though your principal argument is that same sex and opposite camp sex couples are not similarly situated. Because. Opposite sex couples can procreate same sex couples cannot and state principal interest in marriage. Now what happens here argument. About the institution of marriage is tool -- appropriations. The fact. In California to. Couples that aren't gay but can't have children. Get married all the time. Yeah sure the concern is that B defining marriage. As agenda listened completion. Will suffer its abiding connection. To its historic traditional -- -- purposes if you. Redefine marriage to include same sex couples you must. You must permit adoption by same sex couples. And there's there's considerable broad disagreement among among sociologists. As to what what the consequences of raising a child and in it. In in a single sex. Friendly. What whether that is harmful to the children. In -- when you impact. Same sex couples adopting terror that's right here on that is true. Maybe it's true but irrelevant. There you. There arguing for the nationwide. Rule. Which applies to states other than -- point that every state must allow marriage by same sex couples. There's some 40000. Children in California according to the red brief. That lived with same sex parents. And today. Want their -- To have full recognition -- -- Thank you mr. Chief Justice made pleas court I thought that would be important for this court. To have proposition eight put in context what it does. Give walls off. Gays and lesbians from marriage the most important relation in life according to this court thus statement -- A class of California based upon their status. And labeling their most cherished relationships. As second rate. Different. On people and not okay. I'm curious win win to me when did it become unconstitutional. To exclude. Homosexual. Couples from marriage. 79 -- one. 1868. When the fourteenth amendment was adopted. I can answer this in the form of a rhetorical question when did it become unconstitutional. To prohibit interracial marriages but. People -- my sex couples -- every other right it's just about the leave them the label marriage means something even our -- worse if you help. If you tell a child but somebody has to be their friend. Suppose you can force the child to say this is my friend but it changes the definition of what it means to be friend. And that's it seems to me what -- what supporters of proposition eight are saying what are your take all your interest in as the label and you insist on changing. The definition of the legal problem. The problem with the case is that you're really asking particularly because of the sociological evidence -- site. For us to go into uncharted waters. What what is your response of the argument which has already been mentioned. About that they need to be cautious in the light of the newness of the concept. Of same sex marriage. First. California did not proper proposition eight -- what my friend mr. Hu percent which -- it pushed the delete. This is a permanent ban. It's in the constitution is supposed to take this issue out from the legislative process is it position the United States that same sex marriage is not require. Throughout the country. We're not. It we we are not taking the position that is required throughout the country we think that that ought to be left open. For future -- adjudication and and other states that don't have the situation California passed.

Prop 8 & Procreation: high court sails "uncharted waters"

Wednesday, Mar 27, 2013 - 04:51

Top News »

Money »

S&P 500 to new record on improving economy S&P 500 to new record on improving economy

Fri, Aug 29, 2014 - (2:31)

Finding meaning in the S&P 500 2000 mark Finding meaning in the S&P 500 2000 mark

Mon, Aug 25, 2014 - (2:35)

S&P falls back from record high S&P falls back from record high

Fri, Aug 22, 2014 - (1:35)

S&P 500 closes at new high S&P 500 closes at new high

Thu, Aug 21, 2014 - (1:24)

S&P 500 just shy of record S&P 500 just shy of record

Wed, Aug 20, 2014 - (2:23)

Apple hits $100 a share Apple hits $100 a share

Tue, Aug 19, 2014 - (2:06)

Nasdaq closes at 14-year high Nasdaq closes at 14-year high

Mon, Aug 18, 2014 - (2:23)

Putin puts Wall Street in buying mood Putin puts Wall Street in buying mood

Thu, Aug 14, 2014 - (2:10)

The Exchange »

The Exchange: Hot commodity The Exchange: Hot commodity

Wed, Jul 16, 2014 - (9:25)

The Exchange: Constitutional crusade The Exchange: Constitutional crusade

Wed, Jun 25, 2014 - (11:35)

The Exchange: The value of money The Exchange: The value of money

Mon, Jun 02, 2014 - (9:53)

The Exchange: China’s Second Continent The Exchange: China’s Second Continent

Tue, May 27, 2014 - (9:35)

The Exchange: A master of business arts The Exchange: A master of business arts

Thu, May 08, 2014 - (8:24)

The Exchange: America's bankrupt cities The Exchange: America's bankrupt cities

Mon, May 05, 2014 - (8:52)

The Exchange: Let the rocking commence The Exchange: Let the rocking commence

Tue, Apr 08, 2014 - (8:13)

The Exchange: The Moneyball fallacies The Exchange: The Moneyball fallacies

Mon, Mar 24, 2014 - (9:54)

Is doing good a good business? Is doing good a good business?

Mon, Mar 17, 2014 - (7:38)

Reuters Investigates »

Re-homing victim: "I could have been dead" Re-homing victim: "I could have been dead"

Wed, Feb 19, 2014 - (8:24)

Cops and loggers in the Amazon rainforest Cops and loggers in the Amazon rainforest

Fri, Jan 10, 2014 - (4:01)

"Passed around like a dog" "Passed around like a dog"

Thu, Aug 29, 2013 - (6:32)

Adopted, then abandoned online Adopted, then abandoned online

Thu, Aug 29, 2013 - (13:21)

How the DEA keeps its secrets secret How the DEA keeps its secrets secret

Mon, Aug 05, 2013 - (1:36)

How education lost its role as the great equalizer - Reuters Investigates How education lost its role as the great...

Mon, Dec 17, 2012 - (7:52)

Jihad Jane: From abused child to American jihadist - Reuters Investigates Jihad Jane: From abused child to American...

Sat, Dec 08, 2012 - (10:01)

Jihad Jane: The order to kill - Reuters Investigates Jihad Jane: The order to kill - Reuters...

Sun, Dec 09, 2012 - (10:39)

Moving Pictures »

Images of August Images of August

Fri, Aug 29, 2014 - (1:00)

Burning Together Burning Together

Mon, Sep 01, 2014 - (2:23)

Mending dolls, teddies and hearts Mending dolls, teddies and hearts

Fri, Aug 22, 2014 - (3:12)

"Old timers" sail the Chesapeake Bay "Old timers" sail the Chesapeake Bay

Mon, Aug 11, 2014 - (2:27)

Burned memories Burned memories

Fri, Aug 08, 2014 - (3:02)

Images of July Images of July

Thu, Jul 31, 2014 - (1:20)

World Cup: passion on the pitch World Cup: passion on the pitch

Fri, Jul 11, 2014 - (1:00)

A refugee in America gives back A refugee in America gives back

Wed, Jul 02, 2014 - (3:25)

A long search for refuge A long search for refuge

Fri, Jun 20, 2014 - (3:04)

World Cup: Around the globe in 50 goals World Cup: Around the globe in 50 goals

Fri, Jun 06, 2014 - (1:08)