Tax havens talk back against G20 "finger pointing"

GEORGE TOWN, Cayman Islands (Reuters) - Caribbean and Atlantic offshore finance centers are hitting back against attempts to portray them as shady tax havens and say world leaders are making them scapegoats for the global downturn.

The downtown waterfront area of Georgetown, Grand Caymans, the capitol of the island is seen in this handout released September 25, 2009. Caribbean and Atlantic offshore finance centers are hitting back against attempts to portray them as shady tax havens and say world leaders are making them scapegoats for the global downturn. To match feature G20/TAXHAVENS. REUTERS/Alan Markoff REUTERS/Alan Markoff

Leaders of the Group of 20 economic powers, meeting in Pittsburgh on Friday on global economic issues, launched a campaign in April to name and shame tax havens and penalize those who failed to tighten tax standards and transparency.

Spurred by public outrage over big bonus-earning bankers and high-profile frauds by wealthy financiers, G20 governments have pointed accusing fingers at tax havens across the globe, many of them on tiny, beach-rimmed islands in the Caribbean.

As U.S. investigators probe Swiss bank accounts held by suspected U.S. tax cheats, leading offshore jurisdictions say they resent being cast as hide-outs for tax evaders and crooks.

“It’s not fair,” said McKeeva Bush, political leader and Minister of Financial Services of the Cayman Islands, the tiny British overseas territory south of Cuba that is one of the world’s largest domiciles of hedge funds.

He and other policymakers and business chiefs from prominent Caribbean and Atlantic offshore centers say the anti-tax haven “finger pointing” by the world’s richest and most powerful governments is hypocritical and seeks to shift blame away from their own failed policies and lax regulation.

“It’s the fault of the onshore centers who taxed their own people ... money is running away from them now,” Bush said.


“Cayman had nothing to do with the investing in sub-prime derivatives, U.S. housing bubble or gross over-leveraging of the main banks ... It’s a nice diversion to blame the evil guys in the Caribbean instead of laying blame where it belongs,” said Grand Cayman real estate developer Michael Ryan.

“There is a lot of finger pointing at the offshore world,” said Cheryl Packwood, chief executive officer of the Bermuda International Business Association. Bermuda, a tiny Atlantic island that is also a British territory, is a center for the global insurance industry.

But in the United States alone, offshore tax havens are estimated to deprive the Treasury of $100 billion a year. Official efforts to track down tax dodgers have gained pace as the U.S. government seeks to collect more revenues without raising tax rates to offset its vast and growing budget deficit.

After G20 leaders this year declared a crackdown against tax havens, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) in April published a “gray list” of jurisdictions they said fell short of full compliance with internationally agreed tax standards. More than a dozen Caribbean jurisdictions, and Bermuda, were on the list.

But while Caribbean and Atlantic offshore financial centers reject what they see as a one-sided witch hunt against them, their governments have nevertheless scrambled to get themselves dropped from the damning OECD noncompliance list.”

The Caymans and the British Virgin islands achieved this in July after signing at least 12 bilateral tax agreements in line with OECD standards. Bermuda has also moved up to the “white list”, and other Caribbean states are signing tax treaties.

Anthony Travers, chairman of the Cayman Islands Financial Services Association, sees an attempt by the G20 nations to impose what he calls a “new world order predicated on a global one-size-fits-all higher rate of taxation”.

Bermuda’s finance minister, Paula Cox, also suspects the world’s richest states may be seeking “extra-territorial solutions to their economic, fiscal and financial challenges.”

“There is now a strong suspicion that the G20 has an undisclosed agenda item to drive forward a global corporate tax policy, which may fly in the face of a nation’s sovereign right to set down its own tax policy,” she said.

Timothy Ridley, former chairman of the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority, believes the crackdown on tax havens stems largely from fear of competition by “those ... who wish to retain control of the world’s capital and to tax it”.

Some experts in the Bahamas suggested the offshore sector should ensure its future by shifting away from clients in the United States, Europe and Canada to new wealthy customers in emerging powers like Brazil, China, Nigeria, Russia and India.


“If you can provide new services to these markets, you will swim, not sink,” said Julian Malins, a London-based barrister who has acted as counsel for cases originating in the Bahamas.

While insisting they have put their finance sectors in order from the regulatory viewpoint, political and business leaders of these offshore jurisdictions admit their territories have not escaped the battering of the global financial crisis.

“Fewer tourists, lower tourist and consumer spending, the squeeze on business profits, redundancies and lay-offs are all the result of the global recession,” said Bermuda’s Cox.

This has led to some companies leaving the Atlantic island insurance center. This week, directors of global insurance broker Willis Group Holdings WSH.N approved moving its domicile from Bermuda to Ireland, citing economic factors.

But both Bermudian and Caymans business leaders felt their finance centers could weather the economic storm and prosper.

“Money is going to find the right place to be,” said Caymans Leader of Government Business Bush, who is embroiled in a dispute with Britain over the islands’ financial management.

“No matter what (the United States and EU) try to do, the more regulated places will survive and the Cayman Islands will survive,” he said.

Additional reporting by Neil Hartnell in Nassau, Kevin Drawbaugh in Washington; writing by Pascal Fletcher; Editing by Philip Barbara