NEW YORK, June 21 (Reuters) - The lazy days of summer have given way to seasons of tumult, volatility, and for some investors - opportunity.
Last year, Mark Mulholland, manager of the Matthew 25 mutual fund, gave up his vacation because of the debt crisis and gyrating stock market. Since then, the Jenkintown, Pennsylvania-based portfolio manager has led his fund to become this year’s top fund.
The Matthew 25 fund weathered last summer’s storms and rode the subsequent ups and downs well enough to post a 25 percent return, ranking it as the top performing equity-diversified mutual funds of the last 12 months, according to data from Lipper, a Thomson Reuters company.
Overall, small funds performed best, with the Akre Focus Fund (AKREX) posting a second best return of 23.5 percent, followed by the Bretton Fund with a return of 22 percent. Rounding out the top five, the Midas Magic Fund had a return of 22 percent and the Berkshire Focus Fund had 20 percent.
Lipper analyzed the top actively managed, open-end funds - excluding ETFs, sector equity funds and leveraged funds - to capture the ones that had the best returns through the past year.
Now these funds are facing what promises to be another tumultuous summer. Some investors are looking forward to more buying opportunities, all the better if the market is wild.
“The tumultuous summer may or may not happen. That’s a hard game to play,” Mulholland said. “But volatility is not a risk if you’re able to purchase more. I’ve been bullish for three years. Now I’m optimistic.”
Managers of the top three funds argue that holding cash, investing in battered financial companies and considering tech stocks may be smart ways to play the coming summer of discontent.
The average turnover of Mulholland’s fund, which holds about $125 million and has operated since 1995, is just 20 percent.
One key to his strategy is having enough cash on hand to buy when the time is ripe. While he doesn’t hold a big cash position, Mulholland said he’s had some in-flows of cash recently and has been adding to his holdings, particularly Apple , which comprises 17.7 percent of his portfolio, and Cabela’s, which is 6.4 percent of his holdings.
Stephen Dodson, who manages the Bretton fund, has 13 percent in cash, and said he doesn’t make many changes in his holdings either - his turnover rate is 13 percent.
“The level of cash represents how attractive I believe the market is - which is moderately attractive. It’s been hard to find new investments,” he said.
His fund, which holds less than $5 million, started in September 2010, but he said size is probably at his advantage.
“If I had $100 billion, there’s no way I could have produced these returns,” he said.
Charles Akre, manager of the Akre Fund, usually holds between 15 and 30 percent in cash, and is now at 15 percent. He said this is despite significant in-flows of cash - his fund went from $280 million in September to $1.05 billion by this week.
“That is not all performance,” he said of his fund that started in August 2009. “It may very well be that the circumstances of having significant in-flows has been valuable to us, but it has also been a challenge.”
The companies that Akre has considered worth his attention tend to be from the financial sector and consumer services, such as Mastercard, his largest holding. These holdings are either down or flat in his portfolio, he said, “but I never look at things with the point of view of a sector. That’s for other people.”
Instead, he looks for how a company will do over time in relation to how it is priced, and so for now, he’s still adding to his holdings in companies such as TD Ameritrade, Citibank and Markel.
Dodson and Mulholland are also betting on financial stocks, despite the trouble in the marketplace. “Financials have not performed well over the past 18 months, but if you look at longer horizons, these are some of the most attractive stocks out there today,” Dodson said.
Mulholland has his largest investment in Apple, which is 17 percent of his portfolio, and thinks the company still has a lot of room to grow. “It’s worth $850 or $900 a share, and that’s not even an aggressive number,” he said.
Apple closed at $585.74 on Wednesday and was trading at $585.40 at midday on Thursday.
But Dodson operates an Apple-free zone, not out of any dislike for the company or its products, but because it’s hard to predict what they may earn five or 10 years from now. “It’s hard for me not to feel that a lot of the fun has already happened,” he said.
Akre is of the same mind, but has less than 3 percent of his holdings in Apple. “They have historically pulled one rabbit out of the hat after the next,” he said, but, “what are their reinvestment opportunities? That’s why we don’t have a huge position.”
As the summer wears on, however, all are ready to dive into other tech stocks, or whatever company presents itself as an opportunity.
“If there is a catastrophe or major market pullback, it will be a good thing,” Dodson said. “It’s in those market panics that you can find the best opportunities.”
As for Mulholland, despite looming trouble he plans to take a break this summer, only relatively close to home.
“I won’t be going to China or anything. If something happens, I’ll go back to work,” he said.