Top News

U.S. revision on India nuclear trade deficient - diplomats

VIENNA (Reuters) - A revised U.S. proposal for lifting a global ban on nuclear trade with India does not go far enough to defuse fears the move could shred non-proliferation standards, diplomats said on Sunday.

U.S President George W. Bush and India's Prime Minister Manmohan Singh attends a joint news conference at Hyderabad House in New Delhi in this March 2, 2006 file photo. REUTERS/Jim Young/Files

Washington sent a fresh draft plan to fellow members of the Nuclear Suppliers Group on Saturday after many in the 45-nation NSG demanded conditions for waiving their rules to deal with a nation that is outside the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).

The United States needs an unprecedented NSG exemption to help seal its 2005 civilian nuclear energy deal with India. But a U.S. attempt to push through a waiver without substantive conditions was blocked at an Aug. 21-22 NSG meeting.

Six nations, backed by at least 15 more in the cartel, whose decisions must be unanimous, demanded amendments to ensure that Indian access to nuclear markets would not indirectly benefit its atomic bomb programme.

But diplomats said the new waiver text bore only cosmetic changes in the face of Indian insistence on a “clean” exemption and this made it unlikely a follow-up NSG conclave set for Thursday and Friday could agree a solution.

Without NSG action in early September, the U.S. Congress may run out of time for final ratification of the U.S.-India deal before it adjourns at the end of the month for autumn elections. That would leave the deal in indefinite limbo.

“Agreement looks unlikely this week. The red lines of India and concerned NSG members remain too far apart. India will have to give more,” said one diplomat, who like others asked for anonymity as the nuclear bloc’s deliberations are confidential.


The U.S.-India deal is controversial since India has shunned the NPT, which commits members to nuclear disarmament, and a test ban treaty after developing atom bombs with Western technology imported ostensibly for peaceful nuclear energy.

Washington and some allies assert the U.S.-India deal will shift the world’s largest democracy toward the non-proliferation mainstream and fight global warming by fostering use of low-polluting nuclear energy in developing economies.

Diplomats said “like-minded” NSG states remained set on conditions including a trade halt if India tests a bomb again, transfers of fuel-enrichment or reprocessing technology that could be replicated for bomb making, and periodic waiver reviews.

“(Our) red lines are sacrosanct and if these are not met we can’t endorse the agreement,” India’s national security adviser M.K. Narayanan told television channel CNN IBN.

But Daryl Kimball of the Arms Control Association think-tank wrote in a commentary: “The proposal makes no substantive concessions and is essentially the same as the earlier (one). This is insulting, irresponsible and should be flatly rejected,”

additional reporting by Bappa Majumdar in New Delhi