Probe finds 20 percent of China milk companies in scandal

SHIJIAZHUANG, China (Reuters) - Twenty percent of Chinese dairy firms probed in the wake of a baby milk health scare have been found to have produced melamine-tainted formula, state media reported on Tuesday.

A child who suffered from kidney stones receives medical treatment at a hospital in Hefei, Anhui province September 15, 2008. REUTERS/Jianan Yu

Chinese quality officials last week ordered a nationwide probe into all baby milk powders after it was reported that dozens of children had developed kidney stones after drinking tainted formula produced by the Sanlu Group.

Two infants have since died and more than 1,200 diagnosed with kidney illness in a growing scandal that authorities have warned may be yet to peak.

The head of the state-owned company has been sacked.

The results of the government-led probe announced on Tuesday showed that Sanlu Group, which has been the focus of public anger over the scandal, is by far from the only offending company.

Out of 109 dairy producers checked, 22 had been found to have produced batches of milk contaminated with melamine, including Beijing Olympic Games supplier Yili and other major brands, state television said, citing China’s quality watchdog.

State-owned Sanlu, 43 percent owned by New Zealand dairy giant Fonterra, topped the list of offenders with all 11 batches checked found to be tainted with melamine, a banned toxin linked to pet deaths in the United States last year.

Hong Kong-listed Mengniu Dairy was rated as the seventh worst, with three out of 28 batches shown to be contaminated with melamine. Inner Mongolia Yili Industrial Group, a Shanghai-listed dairy firm and Beijing Games sponsor, was also named.

The 69 tainted batches out of 491 tested “would be taken off the shelves, sealed, recalled and destroyed,” the report said, promising “serious” punishment to those found responsible.

Related Coverage

All Shanghai-listed dairy stocks fell their 10 percent limit in early trade but recovered some of their losses later in the day.


Melamine is rich in nitrogen, an element often used to measure protein, and can be used to disguise diluted milk. It is the same additive which caused the deaths of pets in the United States last year from contaminated pet food.

The Municipal Party Committee of Shijiazhuang, capital of northern Hebei province and headquarters of Sanlu, sacked the company’s board chairwoman and general manager, Tian Wenhua, as hundreds of angry parents queued outside the company’s offices on Tuesday.

Tian “bore very large responsibility” for the quality scare, state media portal said in a brief statement on its website, citing the government committee.

Sanlu last week halted production after investigators announced they had found the problem, but the company had been receiving complaints in March that babies’ urine was discolored and that some had been admitted to hospital, officials said.

Local Chinese officials acted last week only after the New Zealand government contacted Beijing, New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark said on Monday.

China’s Health Ministry has pledged free health care for babies sickened by the contaminated milk powder but also warned the numbers of those affected could rise sharply, Xinhua news agency said.

Slideshow ( 3 images )

“... the number of parents who take their children for medical check-ups could rise drastically in the future,” said Deputy Health Minister Ma Xiaowei, according to Xinhua.

Hebei police arrested two dealers on Tuesday for selling adulterated milk to Sanlu, bringing to four the total so far arrested, Xinhua said. One of the newly arrested men ran a farm that produced 3 tons of milk a day.

Police had detained another 22 people for questioning.

Dairy industry experts said that China’s dairy industry had grown too quickly for safety administration to keep up.

“There are no uniform standards and there are loopholes in legal oversight,” Lao Bing, manager of the Shanghai-based Mingtai Dairy Industry Sales Fund, told Reuters.

China has been beset by scandals about toxic and unsafe products in recent years. In 2004, at least 13 babies died after drinking fake milk powder that had no nutritional value.

Additional reporting by Ian Ransom and Chris Buckley; Editing by Jeremy Laurence