Egypt death sparks debate on female circumcision

MAGHAGHA, Egypt (Reuters) - It was a routine procedure undertaken by thousands of Egyptian girls every year, but something went wrong and Budour Ahmed Shaker died while having her genitals cut in a rite known locally as “purification”.

A photograph of Budour Ahmed Shaker is seen during a protest against circumcision, in the southern city of Assuit, about 500 km (311 miles) south of Cairo, in this July 5, 2007 file photo. It was a routine procedure undertaken by thousands of Egyptian girls every year, but something went wrong and Shaker,11, died at a private clinic in the Egyptian village while having her genitals cut in a rite known locally as "purification". REUTERS/Stringer/Files

The death of the 11-year-old schoolgirl at a private clinic in the Egyptian village Mughagha in June prompted the government to outlaw the custom of female genital mutilation, which is so widespread in Egypt that 95 percent of the country’s women are estimated to have undergone the procedure.

But the ban may be hard to enforce and activists fear the practice may go underground as the vast majority of Egyptian families still view circumcision as necessary to protect girls’ chastity. Most girls are cut by the time they reach puberty.

Even in Mughagha, a village of low rise houses hemming the Nile, many women and girls say they want the procedure to be allowed but under more stringent medical supervision.

“If a girl is not purified, she will just go hook up with men. This protects women’s honor. Otherwise it will become just like America here and girls will go with guys,” said Asma Said, a 16-year-old secondary school student.

“Those who say it doesn’t happen are lying 100 percent. There is not one person here not circumcised, and it will continue.”

She like many of the schoolgirls in Maghagha who spoke to Reuters said they supported the practice, even if they were frightened of having it done.

The only girl who spoke against the practice was shouted down by her classmates until she conceded that genital cutting was a necessity.

“No one can get married without it,” said the girl.

Related Coverage

Another classmate, 15-year-old Nesma Radi, chimed in: “Egypt lives in peace and security because there is circumcision.”

Egypt imposed a complete ban on female genital cutting -- also known as female genital mutilation or circumcision -- in June after Shaker died of an excessive dose of anesthesia while being cut at a private clinic in Maghagha.

Egypt’s state-appointed Grand Mufti, the government’s official arbiter of Islamic law, decreed in June that female genital cutting was forbidden by Islam, in his strongest statement yet against the practice.

In Egypt, the cutting is done on both Muslim and Christian girls and typically involves excising the clitoris and sometimes other female genitalia, often by a doctor. Side effects include hemorrhage, shock and sexual dysfunction.

Outside of Egypt and Sudan to the south, the practice is extremely rare elsewhere in most of the Arab world but is common in Eritrea, Ethiopia and Somalia.

More than 95 percent of Egyptian women had been circumcised, with the highest levels in poor families living in rural areas of the Nile valley in southern Egypt, according to an Egyptian Demographic and Health Survey conducted in 2005.


The highly publicized death of Budour Shaker at the start of what activists call Egypt’s “circumcision season”, spanning the hot summer months when school is out of session, prompted Cairo to close a legal loophole that had allowed doctors to perform the rite for documented “health reasons”.

Slideshow ( 3 images )

Like Shaker, nearly three quarters of girls who are circumcised in Egypt are cut by medical personnel, including doctors and nurses who receive fees of 50 to 500 Egyptian pounds ($8.85 to $88.50), activists say.

They say that a handful of girls die each season -- either because they receive an improper dose of anesthesia or from hemorrhage or other complications.

“Some doctors, so that they feel better about themselves and more ethical in a way, say: ‘I’ll prick her’ so she bleeds and her parents are happy ... I’ve heard a lot of doctors saying if I don’t do it they will go to my fellow doctor who will do it,” said Yasmine Wahba, child protection officer at


“I think it’s cuckoo,” she added, referring to the logic. She said she feared the practice may now be driven underground.

Even after the government imposed its full ban on the practice, the procedures continue to happen, although an Egyptian anti-circumcision activist in southern Egypt said doctors were now demanding higher prices to compensate for increased risk.

In the southern town of Edfu, a 7-year-old girl was brought to hospital in July after she hemorrhaged while being cut in a village clinic, the health ministry said.

Health authorities are investigating reports that a nurse in a town south of Cairo had cut the genitals of three girls in a single day in procedures done in their homes. The ministry said the woman, who confessed, could face up to two years in jail.

“At least the doctors will be scared,” Wahba said. “They will be scared because there is a lot of talk now of enforcing the law.”