Q+A: Should Avandia be pulled? U.S. panel says no

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - GlaxoSmithKline’s diabetes drug Avandia should stay on the market, but with extra warnings about heart dangers, U.S. advisers recommended in a dramatic series of votes on Wednesday.

The 33 outside experts convened by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration cast 20 votes for various options that would allow Avandia to stay on the market despite concerns over heart risks.

The agency will make the final decision but usually follows the advice of its advisory committees.

Here are some questions and answers about Avandia:


Diabetes is a serious chronic illness and is a direct cause of heart disease, but several studies have shown that Avandia, known generically as rosiglitazone, may itself damage the heart. Both Avandia and rival drug Actos, made by Takeda Pharmaceutical Co and known generically as pioglitazone, raise the risk of heart failure.

Two studies published last month showed that Avandia raises the risk of heart attack and stroke compared to Actos, but a third study showed that diabetics who took Avandia had a lower risk of heart attack, stroke or death than patients taking drugs of a different type.

The advisers agreed that Avandia does not appear to raise the overall risk of death.

Avandia is a member of a drug class called thiazolidinediones or glitazones. They affect a gene called PPAR-gamma and help the body use insulin more effectively, but have other, broader effects on cells. The first drug in the class, Rezulin or troglitazone, was pulled from the market in March 2000 after 63 people who took it died from acute liver failure and nearly 40 others needed liver transplants.


One of the studies was a “meta-analysis” of 56 trials involving people taking Avandia or other diabetes drugs. Done by longtime Avandia critic Dr. Steven Nissen at the Cleveland Clinic it found those taking Avandia were 28 percent to 39 percent more likely to have a heart attack.

The second study by David Graham and colleagues at the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services found people taking Avandia had 1.25 times the risk of heart failure compared with those taking Actos, 1.27 times the risk of a stroke and 1.14 times the risk of dying.

The third study, paid for by the U.S. National Institutes of Health, found that adding Avandia to the mix of diabetes drugs lowered the risk of heart attack, stroke or death by 28 percent.


That is just what consumer groups such as Public Citizen and Consumers Union are asking.

But the data are not cut and dried, as evidenced by the split votes of the FDA advisers. It can be difficult to show that a drug is dangerous, especially in a disease like diabetes, which is already usually complicated with heart disease and other symptoms as well.

More than 700 pages of internal documents released on Friday showed FDA staffers disagree about how to interpret the studies.

Members of the U.S, Congress, including Republican Senator Charles Grassley, Democratic Representative Rosa DeLauro and Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus, have questioned the FDA’s regulation of Avandia.

A current trial called Tide is designed to directly compare Avandia and Actos.

The European Medicines Agency’s Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use will discuss the issue in London on July 19-22.


The World Health Organization estimates that 171 million people globally had diabetes in 2000 and projected that number will nearly double by 2030 to 366 million.

Diabetes raises the risk of heart disease, stroke, kidney failure and other illnesses. Uncontrolled blood sugar levels can damage the blood vessels, and patients can lose toes, feet and legs to diabetes, while kidneys can fail and damage to the eyes can cause blindness.

While diet and exercise can control diabetes, many people also take prescription drugs.


Diabetics have 12 classes of drugs to choose from.

New drugs include Merck’s Januvia and AstraZeneca and Bristol-Myers Squibb’s Onglyza. Many other drugs are in clinical trials, attacking diabetes with a variety of approaches.

Older drugs such as metformin and a class known as sulfonylureas are available generically and can also help lower blood sugar.

Writing by Maggie Fox; Editing by Lisa Richwine and Tim Dobbyn