England faces regional COVID-19 restrictions despite lawmaker rebellion

LONDON (Reuters) - Parliament approved a system of regional COVID-19 restrictions for England on Tuesday despite a rebellion within Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s own party which underlined growing unhappiness at his handling of the pandemic.

Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson waves as he leaves Downing Street, in London, Britain December 1, 2020. REUTERS/Henry Nicholls

More than 40% of people in England will be subject to the toughest tier of restrictions on their daily life from Wednesday, when the government shifts to its new approach after a month of national lockdown, with just 1% in the lowest band.

“With the spread of the epidemic varying across the country, there remains a compelling case ... for regional tiers in England,” Johnson told parliament, batting away criticism from unhappy lawmakers.

The tiered system has ignited a rebellion in Johnson’s party, with dozens of the 364 elected Conservatives criticizing the plan as draconian, badly implemented or based on insufficient evidence.

“If government is to take away fundamental liberties of the people whom we represent, they must demonstrate beyond question that they are acting in a way that is both proportionate and absolutely necessary,” said lawmaker Graham Brady, head of an influential Conservative committee.

“Today ... I believe the government has failed to make a compelling case.”

The measures were approved by a 291-to-78 vote despite the rebellion because the main opposition Labour Party abstained instead of voting against the government and risking a defeat that would have meant a lapse in all restrictions.

A total of 55 Conservatives rebelled against the government.


The new system dictates what citizens can and can’t do and, while it is less strict than the two nationwide lockdowns England has endured this year, it is still a restriction of social and commercial freedoms previously unheard of outside wartime.

Shops and schools will stay open in all tiers, but in the top tier, pubs and restaurants will be closed except for takeaway services.

Travelling to or from top tier regions is not allowed and mixing indoors with other households is banned in the top two tiers. The government estimates 23 million people will be in the toughest tier and 32 million in the middle tier - together accounting for just under 99% of England’s population.

Johnson responded to members of his party who raised complaints about the allocation of their regions into tiers by acknowledging the difficulty they would cause and promising decisions would be reviewed every two weeks.

“The government will look at how we can reflect as closely as possible the reality of what is happening on the ground,” he said.

He also announced a one-off payment of 1,000 pounds ($1,335) to pubs that would be unable to reopen under the new rules, seeking to address one of the most acutely affected industries.

The United Kingdom has the worst official death toll from COVID-19 in Europe with a further 13,430 cases and 603 deaths within 28 days of a positive test reported on Tuesday. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have separate measures in place.

Tuesday’s rebellion shows how Johnson’s handling of the pandemic has weakened his grip on the ruling Conservatives since they secured a landslide election win a year ago.

Stratford-on-Avon district council, which is run by Johnson’s party and is due to enter the toughest level of restrictions, said on Tuesday it would seek to use a judicial review to challenge the government.

“There is a widespread feeling of disbelief and anger locally,” said council leader Tony Jefferson.

($1 = 0.7492 pounds)

Additional reporting by Costas Pitas; Writing by William James; Editing by Elizabeth Piper, Alex Richardson and Bernadette Baum