(This 28th December, 2017 story fixes spelling of Dr. Carniol’s name throughout)
By Shereen Lehman
(Reuters Health) - A sampling of U.S. emergency department records confirms that sticking anything smaller than your elbow in your ear is a good way to puncture an eardrum.
About 66 percent of patients treated for traumatic tympanic membrane perforations had hurt themselves by sticking “instruments,” in their ears, and nearly half of these cases involved cotton-tipped swabs.
“In our experience, cotton tip applicators (Q-tips and similar products) are frequently the instrument that patients will use to clean their ears,” lead author Dr. Eric Carniol, an otolaryngologist at the University of Toronto, told Reuters Health by email.
“Our conjecture is that the majority of these injuries were caused by patients trying to get their own ear wax out,” he said.
The tympanic membrane, or eardrum, is a structure that transmits sounds from the outer ear to the bones inside the ear, and perforating the membrane can lead to hearing loss, Carniol and his colleagues write in JAMA Otolaryngology Head & Neck Surgery.
Otolaryngologists (Ear, Nose and Throat doctors) see many patients in the office with tympanic membrane perforations that are most often caused by ear infections or trauma, Carniol noted.
The current study focused on the traumatic causes of eardrum perforations. Many patients do not realize they can often injure the ear canal, push earwax further in (impaction), or even burst their eardrum, he said.
The researchers looked at five years of records from 100 nationally representative emergency departments in the U.S. and found over 900 visits for ear-related injuries. These represent almost 5,000 emergency department visits for tympanic membrane perforations nationally during the same period, the researchers write.
About 60 percent of patients were male, and most were 18 years old or younger. “Ear canal instrumentation” was the cause of injury in 61 percent of cases, and 45 percent of these specifically involved cotton-tipped applicators, the study found.
For children from infants to 5 years old, foreign instruments were the cause of 86 percent of injuries and for 6-to-12-year olds, it was 66 percent. Among adults 37 to 54 years old, sticking foreign objects in the ears caused 53 percent of perforations and among those 55 or older, it was 67 percent.
Besides cotton swabs, other objects included hairpins, toys, combs, pencils, straws, toothpicks and lollipop sticks.
Water activity, such as water skiing and diving, was also an important cause of injuries particularly among teenagers and 19- to 36-year-olds, Carniol said.
Still, he said, “If you’ve taken away nothing else from this interview and the article, it is please, do not use Q-tips to clean your ears.”
Carniol said many patients come into his office asking how they should clean the wax from their ears.
“Earwax is made in the outer 1/3 of the ear canal, and it is water-soluble. Therefore, after a shower, most people can get away with just using a washcloth to wipe the wax away from the ear,” he said.
It’s a nice study of emergency room visits for traumatic ear perforation, noted Dr. Hamid Djalilian, a professor of clinical otolaryngology at the University of California, Irvine, who wasn’t involved in the research. But the study “doesn’t capture all the patients who had this problem in the U.S. because it doesn’t include patients who sought care in an outpatient setting such as an urgent care, primary care physician, or ear nose and throat specialist,” he told Reuters Health by email.
The ears have a self-cleaning mechanism, said Djalilian. “This means that the dead skin of the ear canal along with the earwax gradually move outward and come out of the ear on their own.” Therefore, using a Q-tip (or anything else) is almost never necessary and nearly always will just push in the wax deeper into the canal rather than remove wax.
“A little bit of wax will stick to the Q-tip and make the user feel great about themselves that they accomplish something, but chances are approximately 5-10 times more wax was pushed in,” Djalilian said.
Using Q-tips (or other things) in the ear canal is also the leading cause of ear canal infections as it scratches the ear canal skin and allows bacteria to enter the skin causing an ear canal infection (otitis externa), he noted.
SOURCE: bit.ly/2BMihsf JAMA Otolaryngology Head & Neck Surgery, online December 21, 2017.