MADRID (Reuters) - Spanish news organizations are being forced to cut staff and budgets as advertising revenues plummet, eroding the quality and range of the media at a time when the country is facing its worst economic crisis in a generation.
Media companies across southern Europe are feeling the strain as advertising spending falls in line with collapsing consumer confidence. But only Greece is expected to perform worse than Spain this year.
“For the quality of journalism, these are difficult times,” said Carlos Barrera, professor of Modern Spanish Media and Politics at the University of Navarra.
Following Spain’s transition to democracy in the late 1970s, dozens of newspapers and broadcasters started up.
Since 2008, 57 outlets have closed and 8,000 journalists have lost their jobs. For the rest of Spain’s 40,000 journalists, their average salary has more than halved since the country’s boom turned to bust four years ago.
Speculation is mounting that Madrid may have to take the drastic step of seeking a full international bailout to prop up its tottering economy. But even-handed newspaper coverage of such a rescue now looks remote.
“The situation, with this level of unemployment, with effectively fewer media outlets, and this level of uncertainty, means we’re losing democracy,” said Elsa Gonzalez, President of the Federation of Spanish Journalist Associations (FAPE).
As the centre-right government makes deep cuts to try to drag Spain out of the crisis, a narrower range of media is covering events, leaving the influential left-leaning El Pais newspaper and its sister radio station Cadena Ser as the only large media outlets likely to take a critical stance on the government.
After El Pais, the next two most popular generalist papers, El Mundo and ABC, tend to the right and are more sympathetic towards the increasingly unpopular People’s Party.
Spain’s only mainstream left-wing newspaper, Publico, cancelled its print edition earlier this year and now only operates online.
In recent months, right-leaning media have stopped using the word “cuts” and use “adjustments” instead.
But with the mainstream press recording a 12.5 percent fall in circulation in the first four months of the year, Spanish newspapers are struggling to make their mark.
Budgets are under pressure and editors increasingly rely on political opinion pieces, news agency copy and celebrity gossip to attract readers and stay in business. Reporters have fewer opportunities to travel to cover stories.
“Everyone’s looking for a way to differentiate themselves from the competition, but at the same time, with fewer ways to do that, there’s more uniformity,” said Barrera.
Three of Spain’s four free newspapers, which were popular with a commuters whose numbers are shrinking as unemployment rises, have closed, with only one publishing an online version.
Total advertising spending will fall by 12 percent in Spain this year, according to media agency ZenithOptimedia. That compares to a 10 percent fall in Portugal and a 5 percent dip in Italy, and rises of 1 and 2 percent in France and Germany.
According to consultancy Infoadex, overall Spanish newspaper advertising halved between 2007 and 2011 to 967 million euros ($1.2 billion).
Prisa, the media group which owns El Pais as well as educational publishing and pay-TV operations, lost 61 million euros ($76 million) in the first half of the year, despite growth in Latin America. Ad sales dropped more than 10 percent and now make up 22 percent of revenues from 23.4 percent a year earlier.
Television advertising fell by 16 percent in the first six months of 2012, according to Infoadex, denting the profits of Spain’s main broadcasters - Mediaset Espana, part of Silvio Berlusconi’s media empire, and Antena 3.
“In terms of print media, you’ve got a bit of a perfect storm,” said Harjinder Singh-Heer, managing director of media analysis firm G2Mi. “On the television side, the story may be a little bit more attractive.”
Mediaset and Antena 3 operate a near duopoly with 48 percent audience share and so are well placed to negotiate prices with advertisers if the Spanish economy picks up, he said.
Prices for advertisements on private channels soared after the government halted ads on public channels in 2010, said Jonathan Barnard, head of forecasting at ZenithOptimedia.
If Antena 3 successfully merges with smaller rival La Sexta, the independent broadcasters would be further strengthened.
BEYOND THE BUBBLE
Spain finds itself in a more difficult situation than its neighbors because the media sector had grown too big since the 1970s. Pre-crisis it was not unusual for provincial cities to have several newspapers and TV stations.
“There was a bubble, there were hundreds of newspapers, advertising couldn’t stretch to a crisis,” said Bernardo Diaz, director of the journalism department at the University of Malaga.
Total advertising spending in traditional media hit a peak of 8 billion euros ($10 billion) in Spain in 2007. Spain, like other countries, has also been hit by a general shift in consumer habits to access media online, but the severity of its crisis has accelerated and accentuated this process.
Analysts and companies expect the ad market to pick up in Spain next year, but that depends on an improvement in the economy and in consumer confidence, which is unlikely in a country where retail sales have fallen for two years.
ZenithOptimedia said default in two euro zone countries would drag advertising spending in western Europe down 4 percent.
“Everything depends on the evolution of the crisis. It’s also about finding new business models,” said Diaz.
PUBLIC TELEVISION CONTROVERSY
Spain’s public broadcasters don’t have it much better than the private stations, sacking staff as the government slashes spending to meet EU budget rules.
The ruling People’s Party was criticized for using its parliamentary majority to choose a new head for state broadcaster RTVE.
Since the PP put Leopoldo Gonzalez-Echenique, from hotels group NH, in charge of RTVE in June, several prominent journalists and the head of news have been forced out.
The dismissal of popular news presenter Ana Pastor, admired for her tough interviewing technique, has particularly stirred up controversy.
Pastor, presenter of RTVE’s flagship breakfast show, was offered another programme, the station said. Pastor disagreed.
“Whatever they say ... I know they got rid of me for doing journalism,” she said on Twitter.
The government has cut its budget for RTVE by 37 percent this year. News agency EFE, in which the government holds a majority stake, is also floundering as sales in the Spanish market and its government funding fall, leading to lay-offs.
“Drowning public media like RTVE and EFE will reduce the quality of information and therefore democracy,” said FAPE’s Gonzalez. ($1 = 0.8132 euros)
Additional reporting by Borja Gonzalez; Editing by Fiona Ortiz and Giles Elgood
Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.