NEW YORK (Reuters) - Timothy Geithner’s biggest selling point as nominee for U.S. Treasury Secretary may haunt him when the Senate considers him for the post: his deep involvement in combating the global financial crisis.
Thus far the 47-year old Geithner has been somewhat of a golden child for politicians, bankers and the media.
His nomination last month was welcomed with open arms, and observers generally showered him with praise. The stock market rallied off 11-year lows on the day of the announcement.
Yet with the economy flailing and credit markets far from settled, the number of voices criticizing him have increased. While he would bring experience of the steps the Federal Reserve and U.S. Treasury have taken to try to restore financial stability, he may also be partly tarnished by their failures.
As president of the New York Federal Reserve Bank, Geithner has worked hand-in-glove with Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson in putting in place a stunning array of emergency measures to prop up the financial system.
He was also heavily involved in the widely condemned decision to let investment bank Lehman Brothers fail, which sent the already fragile financial system into a steep downward spiral.
“He’ll get roughed up ... for letting Lehman fail, and for the Fed not doing more to minimize (home) foreclosures,” a senior Senate Democratic aide said. Still, the aide predicted the nomination would get through the Senate, which must sign off on it, with relative ease.
With the economy’s malaise showing no sign of letting up, no one who has battled the crisis is escaping unbloodied.
The rescue measures, which have succeeded in stabilizing the banking system and lowering interbank borrowing rates for now, have not yet been able to reverse an economic slowdown that has proven to be the most worrisome since the Great Depression.
“There were quite a few missteps,” said Christopher Low, chief economist at FTN Financial.
The most widely criticized decision is the one to let Lehman Brothers fail in mid-September, even as authorities moved to bailout insurer American International Group.
David Kotok, chief investment officer at Cumberland Advisors, laid out some questions he would like Congress to drill Geithner on:
“Did you and your weekend colleagues consider the contagion that would follow if Lehman failed and triggered counterparty failure? Did you see the global collapse coming because of Lehman’s failure? Did you realize that risk premiums would spike in all financial sectors if a primary dealer failed? If so, why did you permit it?”
The New York Times also dug into Geithner in an editorial this week, criticizing the New York Fed chief and his central bank colleagues for being evasive in explaining what happened.
Bernanke told Congress shortly after Lehman failed that the Fed and Treasury had decided not to commit public funds to support the investment bank because they believed investors and counterparties had known the troubles at Lehman for some time and had time to take precautionary measures.
But since then, Geithner and his colleagues have changed their tune, arguing that the Fed lacked the authority to give Lehman a loan because it lacked adequate collateral.
Another brush which has tarred other regulators also tars Geithner.
While he was ahead of the curve in seeing the need for a central counterparty clearing house for derivatives, Geithner and other regulators did not foresee the depth of the fallout from the housing crisis, and the warnings he did offer did not prompt immediate action.
Still, analysts said Geithner’s resume for Treasury is by no means lacking. He has had a distinguished career in government, and played a big part in U.S. policy during the Asian and Russian economic crisis in 1997-1998.
“It was a great choice,” said Kurt Karl, head of economic research and consulting at Swiss Re. “He is a crisis management expert.”
It’s that expertise that got him the nomination, but it might make the road to confirmation a little more tortuous.
Additional reporting by Thomas Ferraro in Washington