NEW YORK (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - Jeannine Cook had only opened her Philadelphia bookstore for a few weeks when the coronavirus forced its closure, the latest in a string of obstacles for the Black business owner.
Landlords refused to rent to her, and, like many Black-owned businesses, her Harriett’s Bookshop was too new and small to be eligible for a U.S. government Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loan to help small businesses weather the COVID-19 setbacks.
“The fact I’m a woman, the fact that I’m young, the fact that I’m Black, the fact that I’m urban ... I would be silly not to think those things don’t play a part,” said Cook, who has renewed her lease while worrying about reopening too soon.
“Do I think there’s prejudice and institutional racism? I think that’s 100% sure we know that,” she told the Thomson Reuters Foundation. “The thing about racism is that it hides, and it’s very covert, and so it’s able to live in the shadows.”
Often unwelcomed by mainstream financial institutions and facing racist practices in business, Black Americans have suffered financial inequality for decades.
Confronted by racist hiring practices, Black Americans historically have been shunned from the best paying jobs and lack the generational wealth often available to white Americans.
And the inequality is worsening. According to U.S. think tank the Brookings Institute, the gap between white and Black family wealth is higher today than it was at the start of the century.
“Being Black in America is hard,” said Dexter George, who turned to online fundraising to keep his Source of Knowledge bookstore in Newark, New Jersey, from closing due to the pandemic after more than two decades.
“But being Black in business is even harder.”
Now, along with higher rates of hospitalization and death due to COVID-19 than their white peers, Black Americans are being hit harder by the pandemic’s economic fallout, losing jobs, businesses and opportunities for advancement.
“COVID-19 is a pandemic within a pandemic for Black people in this country,” said Jennifer Epps-Addison, co-executive director of the Center for Popular Democracy, a U.S. advocacy group.
“The racist systems in America ... that have regularly failed Black people for generations, are now less reliable amid this pandemic.”
In July, Black unemployment was 14.6%, government data showed, while the joblessness rate for whites was 9.2%, a gap of 5.4 points.
This was the widest gap in jobless rates between Black and white Americans in more than five years, according to the Labor Department, exposing a critical economic aspect to inequality at a pivotal moment in U.S. race relations.
‘WE ARE IN EXTREME CRISIS’
Efforts at moving stimulus money into the battered U.S. economy has hit an impasse, with the Republican-led Senate and Democratic-controlled House of Representatives in an informal recess.
Their negotiations are wide apart - the Democrats’ proposal is $3 trillion and the Republicans’ is $1 trillion, with gaps in proposed funding for schools, state and local governments and unemployment benefits.
“We are in extreme crisis. I think we are in a greater crisis than at any time in the 21st century,” said Marc Morial, president of the National Urban League, a top civil rights group.
“We’ve lost ground when it comes to home ownership, substantial ground, and with the economic crisis that undergirds the situation, it is likely that the Black home ownership rate will decline even further.
“The coronavirus unmasked many factors, many problems, many issues, many disparities that people ignored, chose to ignore or chose to be indifferent about.”
The vast gap is rooted in a system of housing discrimination called redlining, a government classification system from decades ago that discouraged banks from lending in Black neighborhoods by identifying them as too risky for investment.
As the economic and public health crises collide, Black Americans fear the worst.
Jamie Collins, who lost her information technology job due to the coronavirus, said potential employers see Black people as more likely to get sick from COVID-19, making them a liability.
“I don’t think anyone wants to hire us anymore,” she said. “We, as Black people, are now considered risk hires, and that’s how it’s going to be because COVID is not going away.
“I have to work 10 times harder so I can prove my worth, and I’ve always had to do that. But with COVID, it’s just like I don’t even get to prove it now.”
‘BACK FROM THE STARTING LINE’
For many Black business owners, the hurdles are laid out from the beginning.
More than half of Black business owners did not receive the amount of funding they requested from banks or other financial institutions, compared with about a quarter of whites, according to a 2018 study by the U.S. government’s Small Business Administration.
Almost half of African-Americans said they did not receive the full amount they requested from home equity loans, compared with just over a quarter - 27.5% - of white applicants.
“Getting funding, getting a loan, Black-owned businesses are already 100 feet back from the starting line,” said Mapate Diop, co-owner of a clothing store called Diop in Detroit.
“It might be that people don’t take you seriously. It might be that people just think that you serve a very niche market,” Diop said. “It can be very much a death by a thousand cuts.”
A lack of generational wealth is also a significant barrier, said Marvin Owens Jr., senior director of the economic department of National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, a civil rights group.
Black families have a median wealth of $17,000, compared to White families who have on average $171,000. About 44% of Black families own their homes, compared with 74% of White families, according to U.S. government data.
“Where do you get the down payment when you’re already in a situation where the wages are low or you can’t go to a parent to help you out?” Owens said.
In New York City, Ouigi Theodore, who runs Brooklyn Circus, a style and clothing store, said he sees the difference between white- and Black-run businesses as those who get a cultural pass, and those who don’t.
“Those with the access and those with the money and those with the connections ... are the ones that continue to get the opportunities to make the mistakes,” he said.
He said Black businesses and Black entrepreneurs don’t get as many opportunities to stumble.
“Let’s say I get a loan and something happens and I lose the money. Am I going to get the opportunity to get another loan? Am I going to get the opportunity for that loan to be forgiven?” he said.
“We get one shot. If I get in trouble for something, I’m forever that guy.”
Generational support is lacking as well, he added.
“My grandmother does not have the savings to invest in my business,” he said. “When you’re launching, it is what it is.”
CRISIS AFTER CRISIS
Racism in banking and lending reared its head during the subprime mortgage crisis leading up to the 2008 recession, said Jacob Faber, associate professor of sociology and public service at New York University.
“We saw widespread discrimination there, which resulted in fully erasing the home-ownership gains since the Civil Rights era among African-Americans,” he said.
Faber said the finance industry had long been a driver of racial inequality, with banks less commonly found in communities of color than in white communities.
“Branches in communities of color are more expensive than they are in white communities,” he said. “Communities of color are more likely to have alternative financial services like payday lenders.”
The 2008 financial crisis made such barriers even tougher.
Before the 2008 crisis, the average Black family earned 64% of what a white family brought home, according to U.S. government data. More than a fifth of Black people in 2008 earned less than $15,000, double the share of whites.
As the crisis hit Black unemployment soared to 16% in 2009, while not quite reaching 9% among white workers.
By 2019, the earnings gap grew, and the average Black household earned 59% percent of what a white household earned, according to a U.S. Congressional report.
“We’re still trying to rebuild from that crash,” said the NAACP’s Owens.
“When your margins are razor-thin, a downturn can affect your ability to remain stable, and the sense of instability is just palpable in our community.”
This year as the pandemic struck, between February and April the number of Black-owned small businesses fell 41%, more than twice the rate of white-owned small businesses, according to research by Robert Fairlie, a professor of economics at the University of California, Santa Cruz.
After June, the number of Black-owned small businesses was down 19%, compared with 5% of white-owned businesses, according to the research, published by The Pew Charitable Trusts, a public policy nonprofit.
Andrea Powe of Atlanta lost clients in the 2008 crash. Now, she’s been waiting since June for a small business PPP loan to support her hair studio and A Concrete Rose Production company with 17 employees.
“We’re at a halt. It hit us, it hit the country, it hit my family,” she said.
“I don’t think I’m going to make it through right now. I had all the hope in the world because I’m not a quitter. But right now, with no PPP, no money, and if we go on another lockdown, I don’t know,” she said.
“When you have a lot of people that count on you, it wears heavy. It wears you really heavy.”
Black women earn 62 cents for every dollar earned by white men, according to Equal Pay Today, an U.S.-based project that measures gender and racial pay gaps.
That amounts to nearly $1 million in lost income in the career of a Black woman, according to LeanIn.org, a U.S. women’s advocacy group.
‘BLACK WALL STREET’
With the economic gap between Black and white likely to widen amid the coronavirus crisis, some communities are looking for their own solutions to financial racial inequality.
Kevin Cohee, head of OneUnited Bank, the nation’s largest Black-controlled bank, says having more Black-owned banks could be an important first step.
“The dream has always been to organize the buying power of Black Americans and our allies so we can use money as a tool to allow us to accomplish our political and social goals,” he said.
A Black lender or a Black bank would not look at a customer in a racist way, he said.
At the bookstore in Newark, George imagines a new Black Wall Street offering credit, loans and other financial investments to support Black businesses.
He described being turned down by a bank for a pass-book loan, a system in which a bank will extend a loan using a customer’s savings deposit as collateral.
A bank rejected his request for a loan, even with $45,000 in his savings account, he said.
“I walked out of the bank so disappointed, so heartbroken,” he said.
“How could we survive as a people if we can’t get loans? How could we survive if our houses in our neighborhoods are worth less than the white neighborhood?”
The original so-called Black Wall Street was a thriving Black American district in Tulsa, Oklahoma, destroyed in racial violence in 1921. More than 2,000 Black-owned businesses and homes went up in flames and about 300 people died.
“Black Wall Street was burned out from under us,” George said. “Black Wall Street, everybody’s waiting on us to start it.”
Reporting by Matthew Lavietes, Oscar Lopez and Ellen Wulfhorst. Writing by Ellen Wulfhorst. Editing by Belinda Goldsmith. Please credit the Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, that covers the lives of people around the world who struggle to live freely or fairly. Visit news.trust.org
Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.