Change Suite

'Extremely annoying': Siemens Energy ups pressure on wind division

3 minute read

Christian Bruch, Chief Executive Officer of Siemens Energy AG attends Siemens Energy's initial public offering (IPO) at the Frankfurt Stock Exchange in Frankfurt, Germany, September 28, 2020. REUTERS/Ralph Orlowski

  • Q3 orders down 37% at 5.95 bln euros
  • 2021 adj EBITA margin pre one-offs seen at 2% to below 3%
  • Siemens Energy: absolutely not satisfied with onshore
  • Siemens Energy fall to bottom of DAX

FRANKFURT, Aug 4 (Reuters) - Siemens Energy (ENR1n.DE) cranked up the pressure on wind turbine division Siemens Gamesa (SGREN.MC) on Wednesday, saying it was "extremely annoying" that it was forced to slash its profit outlook because of the Spanish-listed unit.

The comments from CEO Christian Bruch highlight the problems around the arm's length relationship he inherited after Siemens Energy's spin-off from Siemens AG (SIEGn.DE) last year, handing him a majority in a business he effectively cannot control.

Bruch, 51, said slow progress in tackling problems at Siemens Gamesa's onshore business, coupled with a lack of transparency, were the main issues that needed fixing.

"The onshore area is absolutely not satisfying," Bruch told journalists after unveiling a net loss and 37% drop in orders for the third quarter, blaming a weak performance at Siemens Gamesa, in which Siemens Energy owns 67%.

"Of course our expectation was that problems can be brought under control significantly faster."

Siemens Gamesa declined to comment.

Shares in Siemens Energy fell as much as 3.4% to the bottom of Germany's benchmark DAX (.GDAXI) index, while Siemens Gamesa's stock rose as much as 2.1%, partly boosted by hopes that Siemens Energy might buy the remaining stake.

Credit Suisse analysts said expectations for a more complex energy market, where offering both renewables and integrated solutions would be critical, "suggests the attractiveness of getting full control of (Siemens Gamesa) in the longer run".


Sources told Reuters last month that Siemens Energy, which supplies turbines and services to utilities, was exploring ways to get full control of the division in order to increase its influence and end its role as a helpless bystander. read more

When asked about this, Bruch said a purchase of the remaining 33% stake in Siemens Gamesa - currently worth 5.35 billion euros ($6.34 billion) - was not his top priority.

Siemens Energy, in charts published alongside results for its third quarter ending June 30, said it was in close alignment with Siemens Gamesa's board regarding "remediation measures", without being more specific.

Siemens Gamesa, the world's largest maker of offshore turbines, last month issued a profit warning, blaming high raw materials prices and problems related to the launch of an onshore turbine. read more

The Madrid-listed company was formed in 2017 through the merger of Spain's Gamesa and what was then the wind business of Siemens AG.

Siemens Energy, which pulled its margin guidance last month after the division's profit warning, said it now expected an adjusted margin on earnings before interest, tax and amortisation in a range of 2% to below 3% before special items.

Siemens Energy's profit margin stood at 3.5% after nine months of its financial year. Orders in the third quarter fell to 5.95 billion euros ($7.1 billion), while the group's backlog declined 1.9% quarter-on-quarter to 82.6 billion.

($1 = 0.8437 euros)

Reporting by Christoph Steitz, Tom Kaeckenhoff and Isla Binnie Editing by Tomasz Janowski and Mark Potter

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.

More from Reuters