The fish are so popular, 34 million are eaten in a typical June. As they grow scarce in a changing Atlantic, people ponder the unthinkable: a festival without them.
Piercing Portugal’s soul
A priest in a white robe swings an incense burner, leading the way for thousands of marchers as they cram into a winding cobblestone alley decorated with candy-colored streamers in Lisbon’s ancient Alfama neighborhood.
Behind the priest, six men carry a life-sized statue of Saint Anthony, Lisbon’s patron saint, born more than 800 years ago. The musky incense swirls together with the smoke from orange-hot charcoals grilling whole sardines a few streets away. The procession moves along, leaving behind just the smell of the sardines.
In this city, June is the month to celebrate the saints. Almost every neighborhood throws a party, known as an arraial. Some are just a scattering of makeshift tables in alleyways. Others cover several blocks and are jammed with tourists and locals alike. The saints are quickly forgotten in the din of pumping pop music, longing fado songs, brass bands, chattering families, indiscreet lovers and flirty teens. The sardines are not. They’re the star of every party.
The fish are so popular here, fisheries managers estimate that the Portuguese collectively eat 13 sardines every second during a typical June – about 34 million fish for the month.
But as climate change warms the seas and inland estuaries, sardines are getting harder and harder to catch. Just a week before the festival, authorities postponed sardine fishing in some ports out of a fear that the diminishing population, vulnerable to changes in the Atlantic’s water temperatures, was being overfished.
In the last few decades, the world’s oceans have undergone the most rapid warming on record. Currents have shifted. These changes are for the most part invisible. But this hidden climate change has had a disturbing impact on marine life – in effect, creating an epic underwater refugee crisis.
Drawing on decades of maritime temperature readings, fishery records and other little-used data, Reuters has undertaken an extensive exploration of the disrupted deep. A team of reporters has discovered that from the waters off the East Coast of the United States to the shores of West Africa, marine creatures are fleeing for their lives, and the communities that depend on them are facing turbulence as a result.
Here in Lisbon, the decline of the country’s most beloved fish tugs at the Portuguese soul. A nation clinging to the western edge of the European continent, Portugal has always turned toward the sea. For centuries, it has sent its people onto the sometimes-treacherous oceans, from famous explorers like Ferdinand Magellan and Vasco da Gama to little-known fishermen who left weeping wives on the shore.
The St. Anthony’s festival commemorates a 13th-century priest who, church doctrine says, once drew a bay full of fish to hear his sermon. It is the capital’s biggest, most joyous celebration of the year.
At the bottom of the track where two bright yellow funicular trains begin and end an 800-foot vertiginous trip through the Bica neighborhood, a social club and a local cafe have set up for the festival. On this night, it’s mostly locals, though a few German and French tourists have found their way to the party.
Four friends sit around a wobbly plastic table perched outside the G.D. Zip Zip social club. There’s just enough room for others to walk past and get to the homemade grill where the sardines are being cooked. Three of the friends have sardine skeletons and heads heaped on their plates. They talk about the fish that’s as iconic in Portugal in the summer as a hamburger on the grill in America.
This year, however, because of limits on fishing, it’s mostly only frozen fish that are available.
“We listen to it all year round that maybe this year, we will not have sardines,” Helena Melo says.
Fifteen feet up the hill, Jorge Rito, who has been cooking for the club every June for five years, wipes his watering eyes with the back of his hand. He’s just gotten another order and tosses a dozen whole sardines onto the grill in neat rows.
As he flips the silvery fish, each seven or eight inches long, a burst of smoke rises from the charcoal, and he wipes his eyes again.
“Worried? Yes, of course,” he says, removing the fish from the grill and placing them onto a platter. “It is important for our finances, our economies, for us.”
Just as the next generation of humans may pay the highest price for climate change, the youngest generation of sardines is at risk.
Susana Garrido, a sardine researcher with the Portuguese Oceanic and Atmospheric Institute in Lisbon, says larval sardines are especially vulnerable to climate change when compared to other similar pelagic species, such as larval anchovies, which are capable of living in a wider range of temperatures.
Deep seawater upwelling dominates the waters off the western coast of the Iberian Peninsula and keeps the coastal waters cool. But small differences in temperature, especially when sardines are young, can have a significant impact on whether the fish larva dies or grows to maturity, Garrido says.
Other researchers had tested how well adult sardines survived in a variety of conditions, and there was little evidence that environmental variables such as food abundance and water temperature affected the full-grown fish, she says. So she focused on the larval stage of the species.
“We did a bunch of experiments varying salinity and all of these other variables, and they survived quite well,” she says. “It was when you change temperature that everything, yes, fell apart. So they have a very narrow range of temperatures where survival is good.”
Garrido says a recently completed stock assessment shows that the larval sardine population is extremely low.
“This is getting very serious,” she says.
The Portuguese sardine population started to fall about a decade ago, even though there were plenty of adults at the time to sustain large catches. And around the same time, southerly species, such as chub and horse mackerel, slowly moved in.
Chub mackerel, a subtropical species that was once found only in southern Portugal, is now caught all the way up the coast.
“Probably as a consequence of warming, it is now invading the main spawning area of sardines,” Garrido says.
Alexandra Silva, who works down the hall from Garrido, has been managing the Portuguese sardine stock assessment since the late 1990s – pivotal work that the organization uses to decide the size of the sardine catch.
When she started, the northern population of the species was in trouble following a period of strong upwelling that brought unusually cold water to the surface. The southern stock, however, was relatively healthy. And in the early years of the century, the species recovered.
It was not to last. These days, without large numbers of larvae growing to maturity, the population is near collapse all along the coast from Galicia in Spain to the southern end of the Portuguese coast.
All officials can do is cut down on the fishing. But larger forces, especially climate change, are now affecting the stock in ways that fisheries managers cannot control, the two say.
Regulators have tried.
Starting in 2004, they blocked fishing during the spring, when sardines spawn. And for a while, that seemed to work. Between 2004 and 2011, the stock remained relatively healthy, with landings ranging from about 55,000 to 70,000 tons, even if the population seemed to be dipping. (From the 1930s to the 1960s, and as recently as the 1980s, fishermen landed more than 110,000 tons in a year.)
In 2009, the Portuguese proudly announced that the Marine Stewardship Council, an independent monitoring body, had designated the species healthy and sustainable. That year, Portuguese fishermen landed 64,000 tons of the fish. By 2012, however, that number had dropped to 35,000 tons, and the country lost its sustainable certification. Since then, fisheries managers have restricted the number of days a week that fishermen can catch sardines, the size of the catch, and restricted fishing to only six months during a year.
Last year, the catch was limited to about 14,000 tons.
Earlier this year, the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea, a forum of scientists that advises governments about fishery management, warned that it would take at least 15 years to restore the stock at current fishing levels. After the report, European Union regulators permitted fishermen along the Iberian coast to continue at the current 16,100-ton level. But it also required Portugal, which gets the bulk of the quota, and Spain to submit a plan to restore the stock in October, which may well lead to further quota cuts.
Fisheries manager Jorge Abrantes handles landings for Peniche, a sleepy fishing town about 60 miles north of Lisbon. He doesn’t think the fishing industry is the culprit.
For example, Portuguese government stock assessments indicated that the sardine population had decreased by 10 percent to 25 percent in just a few months. Abrantes argues that the dip clearly wasn’t caused by fishermen pulling sardines from the sea, because no sardine nets were in the water during that period. Instead, he says, there are just not enough juvenile sardines to replenish the population.
In Peniche, fishermen Erbes Martins and João Dias sit among piles of nets on a bright but chilly February morning. The two 75-year-old men would prefer to be fishing for sardines. But the fish are spawning, so they’re not allowed to catch them.
Sure, there are other fish they could catch, but it’s not worth it, they say.
Horse mackerel, or carapau in Portuguese, one of the southerly species that now thrive all along the coast, is abundant but doesn’t sell for much at market, Dias says.
“We can’t fish for sardines in October, November, December, January, February, March, six months,” Dias says. “And carapau just doesn’t pay the bills.”
He says the restrictions on fishing sardines are keeping a new generation from going to sea, because they can’t make enough money.
“When we die,” he says, “no one is going to do the work.”
Lisbon’s Graça neighborhood sits at the highest point in the capital, its pastel homes looking down over the city’s six other hills. For the St. Anthony festival, two stages have been set up for music, along with about 20 temporary food and drink stalls.
Luis Diogo Sr., his wife, Rita, and their two children, Luis Jr. and Vera, have come out to join the party. Luis Sr. looks across a picnic table at his son, who is well into his third plate of sardines.
“This is a country between Spain and the sea, so we went to the sea very soon in our history,” he says. The talk turns to the present, and the dwindling catch of the city’s favorite seafood.
Luis Jr. doesn’t pay much attention to his father. He’s too focused on his sardines.
“I would miss this very much,” the 17-year-old says, wiping his lips clean after polishing off the last sardine on his plate.
Edited by Kari Howard
“This is a country between Spain and the sea, so we went to the sea very soon in our history.”